DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Hafiz Ibn Kathir: A Wahhabi and a mujassim - Says great-grandson of Ahmad Rida Khan

**nushentelve** · 05-12-2012, 03:38 AM

Assalam o 'alaykum,

Ibn Kathīr was a student of Ibn Taymiyyah and like his teacher, he too objected to a number views upheld by the Aĥl as-Sunnah wa al-Jama’ah. It was from the ideology of his teacher Ibn Taymiyyah, that the Waĥābī sect was born. Furthermore, Ibn Kathīr, much like his teacher, also agreed to ideas such as the belief of tajsīm, amongst others.

Walikum usalam,

Brother what is your points, unfortunately this is also the opinion of some Deobandi people, esp. those who are not firm in knowledge and are aggressive polemicist. So how can you blame a barelvi if we also have this internal conflict.

Imam Shah Wali Ullah r.a. rejecting the misconception of the Barelvis, Kawtharis, Some Deobandis and rest of Ahle Bidat:

These speculators behaved contemptuously toward the People of the Hadith calling them corporealists and anthropomorphists and saying that they sought refuge in the formula of "without asking how" (bi la kaif). It has become eminently clear to me that this contempt of theirs is unfounded and that they err in their sayings both from the viewpoint of tradition and of reason and that they err in slandering the leaders of the true religion. (Hujjatullah Al-Balighah)

05-12-2012, 03:38 AM	#5
nushentelve Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 459 Senior Member	Assalam o 'alaykum, Ibn Kathīr was a student of Ibn Taymiyyah and like his teacher, he too objected to a number views upheld by the Aĥl as-Sunnah wa al-Jama’ah. It was from the ideology of his teacher Ibn Taymiyyah, that the Waĥābī sect was born. Furthermore, Ibn Kathīr, much like his teacher, also agreed to ideas such as the belief of tajsīm, amongst others. Walikum usalam, Brother what is your points, unfortunately this is also the opinion of some Deobandi people, esp. those who are not firm in knowledge and are aggressive polemicist. So how can you blame a barelvi if we also have this internal conflict. Imam Shah Wali Ullah r.a. rejecting the misconception of the Barelvis, Kawtharis, Some Deobandis and rest of Ahle Bidat: These speculators behaved contemptuously toward the People of the Hadith calling them corporealists and anthropomorphists and saying that they sought refuge in the formula of "without asking how" (bi la kaif). It has become eminently clear to me that this contempt of theirs is unfounded and that they err in their sayings both from the viewpoint of tradition and of reason and that they err in slandering the leaders of the true religion. (Hujjatullah Al-Balighah)
	Quote