DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Prealiitellg** · 05-12-2012, 08:14 PM

I was thinking that maybe Allah (swt) had not intended to add 'except those who are disabled ' because it is something that is obvious given that Allah (swt) is Merciful and all.

I read somewhere that the Qur'an was first revealed in the seventh or the first heaven in Ramadhan. And the Qur'an also says that it is in Loh-e-Mahfuz.

So if a whole ready made copy of the Qur'an was already somewhere in the Heavens and in the Knowledge of Allah, then why did it need editings and additions like the ones I mentioned. Like, Umer Ibn Al-Khattab (ra) upon hearing the verses in which Allah (swt) describes how He creates a human being in the womb, he said 'Tabrakullah ahsanul khaliqeen' Blessed be Allah the best to create. And then the verse was revealed again and what Umer (ra) said was added to them.

So is Qur'an as it is said that it is in Loh-e-Mahfuz, like pearls and all, is it the same Qur'an we have or is it different? Like many verses were abrogated as well and all.

I hope you can understand my confusion and I am sorry I am not able to express my self clearly at this time. Please do answer only if you know what you are saying. And please do not doubt my intentions if my questions sound impertinent.

05-12-2012, 08:14 PM	#6
Prealiitellg Join Date Dec 2005 Posts 423 Senior Member	I was thinking that maybe Allah (swt) had not intended to add 'except those who are disabled ' because it is something that is obvious given that Allah (swt) is Merciful and all. I read somewhere that the Qur'an was first revealed in the seventh or the first heaven in Ramadhan. And the Qur'an also says that it is in Loh-e-Mahfuz. So if a whole ready made copy of the Qur'an was already somewhere in the Heavens and in the Knowledge of Allah, then why did it need editings and additions like the ones I mentioned. Like, Umer Ibn Al-Khattab (ra) upon hearing the verses in which Allah (swt) describes how He creates a human being in the womb, he said 'Tabrakullah ahsanul khaliqeen' Blessed be Allah the best to create. And then the verse was revealed again and what Umer (ra) said was added to them. So is Qur'an as it is said that it is in Loh-e-Mahfuz, like pearls and all, is it the same Qur'an we have or is it different? Like many verses were abrogated as well and all. I hope you can understand my confusion and I am sorry I am not able to express my self clearly at this time. Please do answer only if you know what you are saying. And please do not doubt my intentions if my questions sound impertinent.
	Quote