DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Was hz fatima(ra) eligible to recieve to inheritance of prophet(saw)?

**WaicurtaitfuT** · 01-07-2011, 11:33 AM

You mentioned that Fatimah (RA) demanded inheritance, can you just shed some light on this?

I don't understand why Fatimah (RA), the same woman, who would give her own share of food to feed others, and sacrificed all she had. Why would she demand something that she's not entitled to? Saying that she demanded something, which she didn't have any right over, is suggesting an element of greed. But that just isn't possible- either she didn't demand anything, or she demanded whatever she had right over.

Remember, Fatimah (RA) is one of the very few, who are given the bashaarah of paradise directly in the Quran. If shias are claiming that Fatimah (RA) had demanded something, which she had no right over- then they are telling a major lie.

We are asking the questions under the light of shia narrations... we provided... So answer in accordance to what is asked... And after you answer we will surely answer all what you have asked.(and you wouldn't have asked that question if you had some common sense)

01-07-2011, 11:33 AM	#20
WaicurtaitfuT Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 420 Senior Member	You mentioned that Fatimah (RA) demanded inheritance, can you just shed some light on this? I don't understand why Fatimah (RA), the same woman, who would give her own share of food to feed others, and sacrificed all she had. Why would she demand something that she's not entitled to? Saying that she demanded something, which she didn't have any right over, is suggesting an element of greed. But that just isn't possible- either she didn't demand anything, or she demanded whatever she had right over. Remember, Fatimah (RA) is one of the very few, who are given the bashaarah of paradise directly in the Quran. If shias are claiming that Fatimah (RA) had demanded something, which she had no right over- then they are telling a major lie. We are asking the questions under the light of shia narrations... we provided... So answer in accordance to what is asked... And after you answer we will surely answer all what you have asked.(and you wouldn't have asked that question if you had some common sense)
	Quote