DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Is Harun Yahya a reliable person for Islamic Facts?

**mrllxp** · 01-25-2010, 03:54 AM

I cant believe how he considers this website more deviant than dawateilsami.net, alahazrat.net and all those other barelwi websites. Incredible!!! Sometimes I think some salafi alims just label others deviants without even knowing who they actually are. For example, all naqshbandi sufis are considered deviants cos of ppl like the haqqanis. Has anyone read Sheikh Albani's fatwa on Tableeghi Jama'at. Its as though he has no idea what it is at all. I think he says that in all this time not a single alim has come out of them. What!!!! The fact that it was started by some hanafis in india is probably what they judge it on.

Am I right in thinking that non-arab salafis are more extreme in calling others deviants than arabs (nowadays anyway)?

wassalam

Well, if you look at it Salafi trends, they usually speak worse of Deobandis than Brelwis and extreme Sufis.

For example, if you look at a lot of Salafi websites, their "refutations" sections will have many articles on Deobandis and (particularly) Tableeghis, but very few (if any) articles on Brelwis.

I think this has to do with the fact that Salafis (the disingenuous ones) are more threatened by Deobandis, due to the truth they speak, than the deviant Sufis, because most of their claims are ridiculous to the point that warning against them often isn't even needed.

01-25-2010, 03:54 AM	#9
mrllxp Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 447 Senior Member	I cant believe how he considers this website more deviant than dawateilsami.net, alahazrat.net and all those other barelwi websites. Incredible!!! Sometimes I think some salafi alims just label others deviants without even knowing who they actually are. For example, all naqshbandi sufis are considered deviants cos of ppl like the haqqanis. Has anyone read Sheikh Albani's fatwa on Tableeghi Jama'at. Its as though he has no idea what it is at all. I think he says that in all this time not a single alim has come out of them. What!!!! The fact that it was started by some hanafis in india is probably what they judge it on. Am I right in thinking that non-arab salafis are more extreme in calling others deviants than arabs (nowadays anyway)? wassalam Well, if you look at it Salafi trends, they usually speak worse of Deobandis than Brelwis and extreme Sufis. For example, if you look at a lot of Salafi websites, their "refutations" sections will have many articles on Deobandis and (particularly) Tableeghis, but very few (if any) articles on Brelwis. I think this has to do with the fact that Salafis (the disingenuous ones) are more threatened by Deobandis, due to the truth they speak, than the deviant Sufis, because most of their claims are ridiculous to the point that warning against them often isn't even needed.
	Quote