DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - 4 witnesses for adultery, what if they lie?

**ORDERCHEAPVIAGRASOFTWARE** · 04-23-2012, 11:56 PM

wa 'alaikumussalam wr wb

All Im asking for is evidence from the Quran or Hadith about this "thoroughness" that you speak of. The Quran only mentions "four witnesses".

if you want to see the "thoroughness" in the sharia implementation specifically in the topic you mentioned, the best way to do that is to check on the precedence as set forth by the previous Islamic states. You'll have to dig from the Ottoman empire, all the way down to what ever sources that might lead to the way the same cases handled by the Prophet

(I'm starting with the Ottoman Empire first and then going backward in time as to denote the volume of references, and needless to say that the sunnah by the Prophet

is the one that we should follow, as

was also followed by the previous Islamic states who implement sharia). The cross examination process of the witnesses definitely can be improved upon as long as the methodology is permitted by the sharia.

Allah Knows Best.

04-23-2012, 11:56 PM	#15
ORDERCHEAPVIAGRASOFTWARE Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 437 Senior Member	wa 'alaikumussalam wr wb All Im asking for is evidence from the Quran or Hadith about this "thoroughness" that you speak of. The Quran only mentions "four witnesses". if you want to see the "thoroughness" in the sharia implementation specifically in the topic you mentioned, the best way to do that is to check on the precedence as set forth by the previous Islamic states. You'll have to dig from the Ottoman empire, all the way down to what ever sources that might lead to the way the same cases handled by the Prophet (I'm starting with the Ottoman Empire first and then going backward in time as to denote the volume of references, and needless to say that the sunnah by the Prophet is the one that we should follow, as was also followed by the previous Islamic states who implement sharia). The cross examination process of the witnesses definitely can be improved upon as long as the methodology is permitted by the sharia. Allah Knows Best.
	Quote