View Single Post
Old 04-16-2012, 09:32 PM   #2
shiciapsisy

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
485
Senior Member
Default


Dante Alighieri, a conservative, devout Christian poet, is remembered for his poem "The Divine Comedy", which depicts the Prophet of Islam, our liege-lord Muhammad and his cousin 'Ali in 8th circle of hell. In canto XXVIII, he says:



Since they allegedly caused schism in life, Dante has eternally punished them in a gruesome manner by having their wounds sealed and then reopened by a devil. Needless to say, such blasphemy is passible by death according to the four Sunni schools of law. How troubling then that people considered by many as great scholars and intellectuals of Islam are on record praising Dante's filthy poetry.

Hamza Yusuf, for instance, feels the need to "defend" Dante and even makes light of Dante’s blasphemy commenting that he would like to make a theme park based on the ‘Inferno’: http://adoptingorthodoxy.wordpress.c...nte-alighieri/

Similarly, Hossein Nasr, a perennialist Shiite praised by Hamza Yusuf, quotes Dante often in his works and states:



Now recently Mahmoud Shelton of eShaykh.com, a Haqqani website which is supervised by Hisham Kabbani, cited Dante approvingly, even suggesting that "The Divine Commedy" is an esoteric and spiritual masterpiece:



Guard your iman brethren and be wary of those who address you with sweet, eloquent speech but whose hearts lack ghayra for the liege-lord of creation, sayyidina Muhammad ...
Dante was indeed an obscene Islamophobe - Muslims with any fitra should shun him for this alone.

Muslims also need to remember not to repeat his filth even whilst attacking those who defend it.

Even repeating these things that Dante said is a very serious thing that should be avoided.


Maybe Hamza Yusuf, Mahmoud Shelton and Sayyed Hossein Nasr had read abridged versions and were unaware of the obscene offending verses?

Maybe there are some other factors that make the situation less simple with them, some other type of extenuating circumstances that we do not know?


It is obvious that Muslims must hate Dante and hate his works as a reflection of their love for the honour of Islam and their love for the Holy Prophet Muhammad (saws), Imam Ali (raa) and Sultan Saladin Ayyubi (ra).
shiciapsisy is offline


 

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:41 AM.
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Design & Developed by Amodity.com
Copyright© Amodity