DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Who was the first person to claim Salah of both men and women is same?

**Karpattaisp** · 04-05-2012, 12:45 AM

Assalamu alaykum

I mean to say the hadeeth of "pray as you see me pray" holds good for women also was understood by likes of Mr Albani and Dr naik after 1300 years. No scholar understood that hadeeth before.

Jazakallah brother. Thats what I wanted to confirm...so exactly..no one before albani understood this hmm

Mr. Albani Ofcourse !!!

Zakir naik recently.
He said with the hadith number.

Thanks. But Zakir Naik is still alive so the first one is Mr Albani. Anyone else before him hinted on such a thing?

I wonder how people accuse us of "inventing" things when no women before the time of Albani ever prayed the same as men

I call this an innovation in Deen..a bidah

04-05-2012, 12:45 AM	#7
Karpattaisp Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 367 Senior Member	Assalamu alaykum I mean to say the hadeeth of "pray as you see me pray" holds good for women also was understood by likes of Mr Albani and Dr naik after 1300 years. No scholar understood that hadeeth before. Jazakallah brother. Thats what I wanted to confirm...so exactly..no one before albani understood this hmm Mr. Albani Ofcourse !!! Zakir naik recently. He said with the hadith number. Thanks. But Zakir Naik is still alive so the first one is Mr Albani. Anyone else before him hinted on such a thing? I wonder how people accuse us of "inventing" things when no women before the time of Albani ever prayed the same as men I call this an innovation in Deen..a bidah
	Quote