DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Harun Yahya - True Muslim or another one of jewish scholars in disguise as Muslim ?

**mashabox** · 04-18-2012, 07:28 PM

did i said anything wrong ?? i said if we want to follow Islam correct Islam we should follow reliable scholars not Harun Yahya - but if want to gain some general good info about Islam then whats wrong with Watching his videos if they are useful ? we should gain knowledge eve if its from enemies - but here a knowledge is coming from a Muslim who is working sincerely for Islam , though he is a sinner and his this particular action is of course wrong but that doenst mean we should not benefit from his other videos

if i have said anything wrong then point out - dont be on extremist side thats my rule

(1) The video you linked is not the first one of that type that has come to our notice.
(2) Gheebah is involved when you are saying something that is hidden from public - above episode is public.
Hence your alarm at the possibility of gheebah is not well founded.

Just think of it in this way: Suppose you present to some one a copy of What Happens After Death? to some one then next day you start crying O Lord forgive me I have done gheebah of Shaikh Bulandshahri (RA) by passing on his writings to others. It does not make sense. Good words are meant for circulation. Coming to bad words - if these were spoken accidentally then these of course need to be hidden. That is when we should be considerate to our brothers and sisters. On the other hand if some one is doing bad things openly and is not even aware of it then it is your duty to stop him. At least he should be made aware of it. No one has talked about that.

But the least we can conclude that you need not be alarmed by the possibility of gheebah.
(3) Indeed you can learn good things from him. But this entails the task of identifying good and bad. Clearly you have to learn a lot from some one else.

I hope it removes some of the fog for you. And those extremists - ha I love them as much you love them. Got it?

04-18-2012, 07:28 PM	#31
mashabox Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 623 Senior Member	did i said anything wrong ?? i said if we want to follow Islam correct Islam we should follow reliable scholars not Harun Yahya - but if want to gain some general good info about Islam then whats wrong with Watching his videos if they are useful ? we should gain knowledge eve if its from enemies - but here a knowledge is coming from a Muslim who is working sincerely for Islam , though he is a sinner and his this particular action is of course wrong but that doenst mean we should not benefit from his other videos if i have said anything wrong then point out - dont be on extremist side thats my rule (1) The video you linked is not the first one of that type that has come to our notice. (2) Gheebah is involved when you are saying something that is hidden from public - above episode is public. Hence your alarm at the possibility of gheebah is not well founded. Just think of it in this way: Suppose you present to some one a copy of What Happens After Death? to some one then next day you start crying O Lord forgive me I have done gheebah of Shaikh Bulandshahri (RA) by passing on his writings to others. It does not make sense. Good words are meant for circulation. Coming to bad words - if these were spoken accidentally then these of course need to be hidden. That is when we should be considerate to our brothers and sisters. On the other hand if some one is doing bad things openly and is not even aware of it then it is your duty to stop him. At least he should be made aware of it. No one has talked about that. But the least we can conclude that you need not be alarmed by the possibility of gheebah. (3) Indeed you can learn good things from him. But this entails the task of identifying good and bad. Clearly you have to learn a lot from some one else. I hope it removes some of the fog for you. And those extremists - ha I love them as much you love them. Got it?
	Quote