DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Is this shirk according to Deobandis? And other rulings?

**Intory** · 07-22-2011, 03:54 AM

[QUOTE=Nomadic;639898]

ur statement contradicts a clear hadeeth that states the prophet fears for us shirk like a black ant on a dark rock on a black night

So you are commenting on the hadith with a particular view in mind. I am not a muhadith and so can't comment. People may understand this hadith differently or draw slightly different conclusion. Worshiping self is also a form of shirk. thought one will not be aware of self worship i.e holding one's view to be infalible even in matters of relegion. The khawarij of the past did that and was very catious of shirk and took this type of unyeilding approach.

the hadeeth is clear cut, please bring another interpretation if you are truthful.

This is the problem, anything you dont like you explain away. You have been belittling the importance of tawheed, i give u a hadeeth and u just say 'oh im not a muhaddith'. Why dont u look at the hadeeth and decide for urself?

Also where is your evidence that the khawarij were cautious of shirk. I think you confused them for the prophets and sahaba. They were the ones who were ultra cautious of shirk. The khawarij even indulged in innovations

07-22-2011, 03:54 AM	#33
Intory Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 457 Senior Member	[QUOTE=Nomadic;639898] ur statement contradicts a clear hadeeth that states the prophet fears for us shirk like a black ant on a dark rock on a black night So you are commenting on the hadith with a particular view in mind. I am not a muhadith and so can't comment. People may understand this hadith differently or draw slightly different conclusion. Worshiping self is also a form of shirk. thought one will not be aware of self worship i.e holding one's view to be infalible even in matters of relegion. The khawarij of the past did that and was very catious of shirk and took this type of unyeilding approach. the hadeeth is clear cut, please bring another interpretation if you are truthful. This is the problem, anything you dont like you explain away. You have been belittling the importance of tawheed, i give u a hadeeth and u just say 'oh im not a muhaddith'. Why dont u look at the hadeeth and decide for urself? Also where is your evidence that the khawarij were cautious of shirk. I think you confused them for the prophets and sahaba. They were the ones who were ultra cautious of shirk. The khawarij even indulged in innovations
	Quote