DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Misconception in the translation of Maraqi 's-Saadat

**Coededgeme** · 04-10-2012, 04:28 AM

The text has no error here. As hamdi posted, it says:

Wudu is nullified by any one of the following things:
1/...
2/...
3/...
4/ Sleeping in a position such that the buttocks are not firmly planted onto the ground, such as while lying down or leaning one one's side*
___________________
* As opposed to sleeping in a position with one's buttocks firmly planted onto the ground (or any firm surface), whereby wudu is not nullified. This ruling applies even if he were leaning onto something to the extent that, if it were removed, he would fall down (Hadiyya, Badai, Tabyin, Durr, Radd).
This is the mu'tamad view (though not the view of Imam Abu Hanifah رضي عنه, which is alluded to in the latter part of Shaykh Faraz Khan's footnote).

For anyone studying this book, I would recommend Shaykh Faraz Rabbani's ongoing classes on it, which are free. (See seekershub.org)

04-10-2012, 04:28 AM	#13
Coededgeme Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 334 Senior Member	The text has no error here. As hamdi posted, it says: Wudu is nullified by any one of the following things: 1/... 2/... 3/... 4/ Sleeping in a position such that the buttocks are not firmly planted onto the ground, such as while lying down or leaning one one's side* ___________________ * As opposed to sleeping in a position with one's buttocks firmly planted onto the ground (or any firm surface), whereby wudu is not nullified. This ruling applies even if he were leaning onto something to the extent that, if it were removed, he would fall down (Hadiyya, Badai, Tabyin, Durr, Radd). This is the mu'tamad view (though not the view of Imam Abu Hanifah رضي عنه, which is alluded to in the latter part of Shaykh Faraz Khan's footnote). For anyone studying this book, I would recommend Shaykh Faraz Rabbani's ongoing classes on it, which are free. (See seekershub.org)
	Quote