DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - One million US women to wear hijab for Iraqi woman killed in California

**hhynmtrxcp** · 04-08-2012, 03:47 PM

But here's the real deal. If a non-muslim had died unjustly on the hands of a muslim, and some muslims attempted to show solidarity, a section of the Muslim world would brand him as a stooge of the kuffar using the name of Quran and sunnah and infact brand him as a nonmuslim for supporting the nonmuslim against that muslim.

is that section a majority or a minority?also are they from the same geographic location or another?
you make a very big generalization. and that too on a thread where people are sympathetic towards the muslim sister unjustly killed. it is precisely this attitude of modernists (im not calling you one) who use this very stance everywhere. an example:
" so what if the Qur'an was burnt?Muslims in pakistan burnt the Bible didnt they?"
now compare this to:
"what if she was killed?it is sad but what about all the ahmedis killed at the hands of muslim zealots?why dont they come out to show solidarity with them?this basically shows how educated modern people understand religion better than these bloody mullahs. proof: we stand for the rights for ahmedis. you dont"

from the surface this is a very good argument. but what it basically does is that it bases Islam on the action of a few people. i.e just because a muslim did this and a section (they never state how big is that section) does not condemn it then they think it is legislated in Islam to unjustly kill a non-muslim and then if anybody stands up against this he should be labelled stooges of kuffar.
what a ridiculous analogy.
when this happens these people immediately turn to their 'reference': the western values (in contrast to how bro. Kuffs referred to Qur'an and sunnah) to see what is the right action. naturally this draws them further from Islam.

so im sorry but your statement is very general and implicates more people than it should. many many uneducated modern people would not understand this statement and would do exactly as i said in above para. if it is possible give a link of an incident where this act happened and we can all condemn it not sweeping statements such as your last post. it gives Islam a bad name.

04-08-2012, 03:47 PM	#9
hhynmtrxcp Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 444 Senior Member	But here's the real deal. If a non-muslim had died unjustly on the hands of a muslim, and some muslims attempted to show solidarity, a section of the Muslim world would brand him as a stooge of the kuffar using the name of Quran and sunnah and infact brand him as a nonmuslim for supporting the nonmuslim against that muslim. is that section a majority or a minority?also are they from the same geographic location or another? you make a very big generalization. and that too on a thread where people are sympathetic towards the muslim sister unjustly killed. it is precisely this attitude of modernists (im not calling you one) who use this very stance everywhere. an example: " so what if the Qur'an was burnt?Muslims in pakistan burnt the Bible didnt they?" now compare this to: "what if she was killed?it is sad but what about all the ahmedis killed at the hands of muslim zealots?why dont they come out to show solidarity with them?this basically shows how educated modern people understand religion better than these bloody mullahs. proof: we stand for the rights for ahmedis. you dont" from the surface this is a very good argument. but what it basically does is that it bases Islam on the action of a few people. i.e just because a muslim did this and a section (they never state how big is that section) does not condemn it then they think it is legislated in Islam to unjustly kill a non-muslim and then if anybody stands up against this he should be labelled stooges of kuffar. what a ridiculous analogy. when this happens these people immediately turn to their 'reference': the western values (in contrast to how bro. Kuffs referred to Qur'an and sunnah) to see what is the right action. naturally this draws them further from Islam. so im sorry but your statement is very general and implicates more people than it should. many many uneducated modern people would not understand this statement and would do exactly as i said in above para. if it is possible give a link of an incident where this act happened and we can all condemn it not sweeping statements such as your last post. it gives Islam a bad name.
	Quote