DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - The difference between the Shia Imams and the Prophets?

**natahololll** · 06-12-2011, 07:21 PM

Assalam alaikum

The same argument I raised on shiachat about a year ago, and asked them some straight questions but I did not see anything to tackle this argument. This is what I wrote..

1. what is the difference between Imams and Prophets?

2. What is shia view regarding Qadiyanis? Are they Kaffir? If yes then why?

3. If Qadiyanis are Kaffir for believing in the existence of a Prophet after our beloved Prophet (pbuh) , then what about you who believe in the existence of even greater in status than all Prophets?

4. Is it just about labels? if a person can have all characteristics of Prophets and even more than that without him being labelled as 'Prophet'... does it contradict concept of Khatme Nubuwwah, according to shia?

All opinions are welcome.....except people like aladdin and haideriam, unless they are ready to give me a shock with their fruitful reply.

Note for mods: This is just a list of questions, which gives shia a chance to defend them. I am not propogating Takfeer on shia here... so please don't close/delete this A shia qouted Shah Waliyullah making the same argument. Read their replies and my counter arguments here: http://www.shiachat.com/forum/index.php?/topic/234977740-shia-imamah-and-qadiyanism/

06-12-2011, 07:21 PM	#5
natahololll Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 667 Senior Member	Assalam alaikum The same argument I raised on shiachat about a year ago, and asked them some straight questions but I did not see anything to tackle this argument. This is what I wrote.. 1. what is the difference between Imams and Prophets? 2. What is shia view regarding Qadiyanis? Are they Kaffir? If yes then why? 3. If Qadiyanis are Kaffir for believing in the existence of a Prophet after our beloved Prophet (pbuh) , then what about you who believe in the existence of even greater in status than all Prophets? 4. Is it just about labels? if a person can have all characteristics of Prophets and even more than that without him being labelled as 'Prophet'... does it contradict concept of Khatme Nubuwwah, according to shia? All opinions are welcome.....except people like aladdin and haideriam, unless they are ready to give me a shock with their fruitful reply. Note for mods: This is just a list of questions, which gives shia a chance to defend them. I am not propogating Takfeer on shia here... so please don't close/delete this A shia qouted Shah Waliyullah making the same argument. Read their replies and my counter arguments here: http://www.shiachat.com/forum/index.php?/topic/234977740-shia-imamah-and-qadiyanism/
	Quote