DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - English Translation of Al-Muhannad 'ala al-Mufannad

**Cheaperisdeeper** · 03-22-2012, 05:05 PM

No I can't, some things are not that way, somethings are complex.

But what I have been taught by deobandi ulama is that there generally too things in this regard:

1) Things (etc) introduced into the deen that go against the deen.
2) Things (etc) introduced into the deen that help facilitate the deen.

There is a lot of grey in this as it depends upon the understanding of people, that is as short as it can be made by me.

You got it right.

1) Ihdaath fid Deen - Innovation in Deen. Every such Innovation is Misguidance and leads to Hell.
2) Ihdaath lid Deen - Innovation for Deen.

There is no grey area in between. This issue is clearly black and white

03-22-2012, 05:05 PM	#30
Cheaperisdeeper Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 555 Senior Member	No I can't, some things are not that way, somethings are complex. But what I have been taught by deobandi ulama is that there generally too things in this regard: 1) Things (etc) introduced into the deen that go against the deen. 2) Things (etc) introduced into the deen that help facilitate the deen. There is a lot of grey in this as it depends upon the understanding of people, that is as short as it can be made by me. You got it right. 1) *Ihdaath fid Deen* - Innovation in Deen. Every such Innovation is Misguidance and leads to Hell. 2) *Ihdaath lid Deen* - Innovation for Deen. There is no grey area in between. This issue is clearly black and white
	Quote