DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - English Translation of Al-Muhannad 'ala al-Mufannad

**scemHeish** · 03-22-2012, 05:21 PM

You got it right.

1) Ihdaath fid Deen - Innovation in Deen. Every such Innovation is Misguidance and leads to Hell.
2) Ihdaath lid Deen - Innovation for Deen.

There is no grey area in between. This issue is clearly black and white

Was there a point as to why you asked this?

And as for grey are inn between, i don't mean inbetween I mean with th actually two types. An innovation for deen can become evil IF it is thought to be a part of the deen, such some people I have spoken to in my 4 months with tablighi jamaat think that it is wajib on every muslim (ulama included) to go out for 4 months, 40 days, etc (ulama for 1-3 years). This is obviously not what the elders of tabligh say, but there are some dubious and evil beliefs among the regular tablighi worker.So while tablighi jamaat method is an innovation FOR the deen (and extremely valuable and useful) it can become evil if people start to make it something it is not, ie a part of the deen, fard, wajib, etc. This is just an example of how something good can be made evil and there is grey in this.

But anyway, what was your point?

03-22-2012, 05:21 PM	#32
scemHeish Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 442 Senior Member	You got it right. 1) *Ihdaath fid Deen* - Innovation in Deen. Every such Innovation is Misguidance and leads to Hell. 2) *Ihdaath lid Deen* - Innovation for Deen. There is no grey area in between. This issue is clearly black and white Was there a point as to why you asked this? And as for grey are inn between, i don't mean inbetween I mean with th actually two types. An innovation for deen can become evil IF it is thought to be a part of the deen, such some people I have spoken to in my 4 months with tablighi jamaat think that it is wajib on every muslim (ulama included) to go out for 4 months, 40 days, etc (ulama for 1-3 years). This is obviously not what the elders of tabligh say, but there are some dubious and evil beliefs among the regular tablighi worker.So while tablighi jamaat method is an innovation FOR the deen (and extremely valuable and useful) it can become evil if people start to make it something it is not, ie a part of the deen, fard, wajib, etc. This is just an example of how something good can be made evil and there is grey in this. But anyway, what was your point?
	Quote