DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**AromeWahmaron** · 03-30-2012, 05:55 AM

I'm very wary of posts that attack Yazeed because it is possible that they over exaggerate or outright fabricate things against him.

you made a claim in this post. defend it with some hard evidence from a traditional source that is acceptable across the board, or you should remove that claim. One should be very wary of making claims if there's a possibility of it not being true.

You are write to ask, we should know where this is from. I read it a few years ago when researching the matter of civil wars in Islam, I do not have the refence to hand but will check and definately post it here when I find it IA.

Just to let you know, I consider Muawaiyyah (Ra), Marwan, Abdul-Malik Ibn Marwan and Umar Ibn AbduL-Aziz the great rulers from the Umayyad period. If your surprised at why I have put Marwan amongst them, there is a real possibility according to some scholars, he was born in the era of Prophethood and was present as a very young child at the time of the Prophets farewell sermon in Makkah - which, if accurate, would make him one of the children amongst the Ashab (Ra).

Edit: The reference is not from a classical, reputable Islmaic historian, it was a Muslim orientalist without clear reference. I take your brother and will remove that reference from the above. Definately will be more careful in the future - Jazakallahu-Khairan

Allahu A'lam

03-30-2012, 05:55 AM	#23
AromeWahmaron Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 345 Senior Member	I'm very wary of posts that attack Yazeed because it is possible that they over exaggerate or outright fabricate things against him. you made a claim in this post. defend it with some hard evidence from a traditional source that is acceptable across the board, or you should remove that claim. One should be very wary of making claims if there's a possibility of it not being true. You are write to ask, we should know where this is from. I read it a few years ago when researching the matter of civil wars in Islam, I do not have the refence to hand but will check and definately post it here when I find it IA. Just to let you know, I consider Muawaiyyah (Ra), Marwan, Abdul-Malik Ibn Marwan and Umar Ibn AbduL-Aziz the great rulers from the Umayyad period. If your surprised at why I have put Marwan amongst them, there is a real possibility according to some scholars, he was born in the era of Prophethood and was present as a very young child at the time of the Prophets farewell sermon in Makkah - which, if accurate, would make him one of the children amongst the Ashab (Ra). Edit: The reference is not from a classical, reputable Islmaic historian, it was a Muslim orientalist without clear reference. I take your brother and will remove that reference from the above. Definately will be more careful in the future - Jazakallahu-Khairan Allahu A'lam
	Quote