DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Peapeuddedbaw** · 03-19-2012, 07:13 PM

Assalamu alaykum

The issue is not sufi vs salafee , it is salafee/laa-madhabi vs imam-e-araba. And specially Imam Abu Haneefa RA.

Can they prove that the salafs were not on Quran and sunnah. The famous muhadditeen, mufassireen and pious scholars for 1300 years were not on Quran and Sunnah.

Yes, if you compare the salafees with the false sufees, then surely the false sufees have to return, for that they need not turn to laa-madhabiyah.

The sincere dawah of laa-madhabees is towards furoee masail (which were resolved and approved for 1300 years). It looks attractive because every muslim respects hadeeth and Quran, and that respected is NOT created by the laa-madhabees, it was already created in the minds of muslims by scholars of madhabs. The laa-madhabees are misusing that respect.

You seem to be projecting your experiences with 'ahle-hadis' in the Subcontinent onto the salafi movement in the Arab world. Also, I said their message of following Qur'an and sunnah seems to make perfect sense on the surface. I never claimed that they actually live up to that message.

03-19-2012, 07:13 PM	#11
Peapeuddedbaw Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 426 Senior Member	Assalamu alaykum The issue is not sufi vs salafee , it is salafee/laa-madhabi vs imam-e-araba. And specially Imam Abu Haneefa RA. Can they prove that the salafs were not on Quran and sunnah. The famous muhadditeen, mufassireen and pious scholars for 1300 years were not on Quran and Sunnah. Yes, if you compare the salafees with the false sufees, then surely the false sufees have to return, for that they need not turn to laa-madhabiyah. The sincere dawah of laa-madhabees is towards furoee masail (which were resolved and approved for 1300 years). It looks attractive because every muslim respects hadeeth and Quran, and that respected is NOT created by the laa-madhabees, it was already created in the minds of muslims by scholars of madhabs. The laa-madhabees are misusing that respect. You seem to be projecting your experiences with 'ahle-hadis' in the Subcontinent onto the salafi movement in the Arab world. Also, I said their message of following Qur'an and sunnah seems to make perfect sense on the surface. I never claimed that they actually live up to that message.
	Quote