DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Brothers and Sisters forgive me for asking this question but i have no choice!

**educationonlines** · 03-21-2012, 02:21 PM

Go and try to be frank with her..Talk with her and see if you guys can patch up..Spend some time together and then marry ..If She's a Muslim..its good. If not..try and what if she converts? Allah will grant you much more reward. As Prophet (SAW) said..Your actions depend upon your intentions..your intention is NOT Satanic..Allah will understand this

His intentions may not be satanic but your advice sure is!

It is haraam to "patch up...Spend some time together". Premarital relationships with ghayr mahram women are completely haraam.

Also, "Your actions depend upon your intentions..your intention is NOT Satanic" is an extremely faulty understanding of the hadeeth. The actions have to be permissible actions. Haraam actions cannot be justified by good intentions.

03-21-2012, 02:21 PM	#6
educationonlines Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 478 Senior Member	Go and try to be frank with her..Talk with her and see if you guys can patch up..Spend some time together and then marry ..If She's a Muslim..its good. If not..try and what if she converts? Allah will grant you much more reward. As Prophet (SAW) said..Your actions depend upon your intentions..your intention is NOT Satanic..Allah will understand this His intentions may not be satanic but your advice sure is! It is haraam to "patch up...Spend some time together". Premarital relationships with ghayr mahram women are completely haraam. Also, "Your actions depend upon your intentions..your intention is NOT Satanic" is an extremely faulty understanding of the hadeeth. The actions have to be permissible actions. Haraam actions cannot be justified by good intentions.
	Quote