DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Prophet (pbuh) has knowledge of the unseen

**BonjGopu** · 03-18-2012, 06:07 AM

If you mean that his knowledge was limited in the sense that it was created knowledge, ofcourse it is limited and only Allah's knowledge is unlimited as His Knowledge is not created or given or bound by time, etc. But if unlimited means that he was given all created knowledge, what is wrong with that?

The wrong with it is that some of the knowledge has been negated from the Prophet (SAW) in the Qur'an and elsewhere. ANd there is no such proof (as fas as I know) which states that the Prophet ('alaihissalatu wassalaa) had been given "created" knowledge and not the uncreated one. On the other hand, there are explicit proofs according to which the Prophet (SAW) had not been given created knowledge, including the hadith of al-Kawthar and the hadith of his Sahw in Salaah.

03-18-2012, 06:07 AM	#25
BonjGopu Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 502 Senior Member	If you mean that his knowledge was limited in the sense that it was created knowledge, ofcourse it is limited and only Allah's knowledge is unlimited as His Knowledge is not created or given or bound by time, etc. But if unlimited means that he was given all created knowledge, what is wrong with that? The wrong with it is that some of the knowledge has been negated from the Prophet (SAW) in the Qur'an and elsewhere. ANd there is no such proof (as fas as I know) which states that the Prophet ('alaihissalatu wassalaa) had been given "created" knowledge and not the uncreated one. On the other hand, there are explicit proofs according to which the Prophet (SAW) had not been given created knowledge, including the hadith of al-Kawthar and the hadith of his Sahw in Salaah.
	Quote