DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Prophet (pbuh) has knowledge of the unseen

**DghtRdc** · 03-18-2012, 06:11 AM

The brothers who have posted. Have you even read my original post? I am simply stating that Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) HAS KNOWLEDGE OF THE UNSEEN, with evidence from Quran and Hadith. Nowhere did I mention to what DEGREE the Prophet's knowledge is or how much. Only Allah and the Prophet know that. Stop trying to create arguments based on what type of knowledge or what knowledge the Prophet has. All we know and agree on is that he does have knowledge of the unseen, but the extent to which he has it cannot be argued. The point of this topic is to refute claims against people who deny that Prophet has knowledge of unseen, not to debate on what type of knowledge and the extent or degree of that knowledge. Only Allah knows best.

if you were trying to convince and argue with people that rasulullah (pbuh) had knowledge of the unseen. you would first have to tell us who you were arguing with. who on earth says rasulullah did not posses some knowledge of the unseen?

deobandies? NO!

salafis? i highly doubt it!

the only controversy in this issue is regarding using the title "alim ul ghayb" to describe rasullah (pbuh), as many linguists and scholars state that using this term implies rasulullah (pbuh) has comprehensive/complete knowledge of the unseen.

quite frankly your stirring up the pot for nothing.

stop and think for a second is it wise to stir up trouble the way you are doing on this forum, in countless threads? not every muslim will see things the way you do, get over it!

sure i disagree with some people's practice3 of 8 rakat taraweeh, but does that mean i should follow your method and barge in their taraweeh and start yelling at them to do 20 instead?

03-18-2012, 06:11 AM	#26
DghtRdc Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 517 Senior Member	The brothers who have posted. Have you even read my original post? I am simply stating that Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) HAS KNOWLEDGE OF THE UNSEEN, with evidence from Quran and Hadith. Nowhere did I mention to what DEGREE the Prophet's knowledge is or how much. Only Allah and the Prophet know that. Stop trying to create arguments based on what type of knowledge or what knowledge the Prophet has. All we know and agree on is that he does have knowledge of the unseen, but the extent to which he has it cannot be argued. The point of this topic is to refute claims against people who deny that Prophet has knowledge of unseen, not to debate on what type of knowledge and the extent or degree of that knowledge. Only Allah knows best. if you were trying to convince and argue with people that rasulullah (pbuh) had knowledge of the unseen. you would first have to tell us who you were arguing with. who on earth says rasulullah did not posses some knowledge of the unseen? deobandies? NO! salafis? i highly doubt it! the only controversy in this issue is regarding using the title "alim ul ghayb" to describe rasullah (pbuh), as many linguists and scholars state that using this term implies rasulullah (pbuh) has comprehensive/complete knowledge of the unseen. quite frankly your stirring up the pot for nothing. stop and think for a second is it wise to stir up trouble the way you are doing on this forum, in countless threads? not every muslim will see things the way you do, get over it! sure i disagree with some people's practice3 of 8 rakat taraweeh, but does that mean i should follow your method and barge in their taraweeh and start yelling at them to do 20 instead?
	Quote