[Qvqnubpj]

Salaamu alaiykum
Why is this still a matter of discussion? Seriously brothers. I've warned before. Don't be using your own logic to derive your own meanings. Don't tell me that the verse in the Quran about the shuhada (May Allah exalt them) and the prophets (May Allah's peace be upon them all) means that they're alive physically as they were in the real world. What right do you have to make such a statement. I acknowledge those verses completely and I tell you scholars from islamqa and others say that this is in the barzakh. They are ALIVE. I'm not rejecting that. But they are ALIVE in the barzakh (according to scholars from islamqa). Are you telling me that you hold an opinion other than the ijma' of scholars such as shaykh Ibn Uthaymin RA? As far as the scholars you quoted, I heard someone say Imam Suyuti. You do know that there are claims that he also believes the Mawlid to be something to be celebrated. Is that the "aqeedah of the ahlus sunnah wal jama'ah"? As far as shaykh Hasan Ali and others (May Allah overlook all their short comings), are you telling me that these people are scholars? Do they even involve in the ijma' of scholars? Let us be safe and leave this topic alone.