DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Abu bakr's family versus fatima’s progeny throughout history

**Gcromqgb** · 10-05-2011, 12:43 AM

^

Concerning the funeral: The modern Twelver Shia mind cannot understand the issue of women's modesty. This is why you the very religious Shia parties have female MPs making a show of themselves and so forth, in an attempt to show that Twelver Shia principles are compatible with modern-day women's liberation.

If this is their way, well then this is their way and religion, and they are free to practice their religion until the Day of Judgment. But they should know that Fatimah (RAA) was so modest that she did not wish for people to even view her burial sheet after she had passed away. So this puts to rest all these stories about her not wanting people to see her after her death. The other issue, of people not knowing where her grave is located is (a) false and (b) even if it were true it makes no difference, since we have no idea where most of the Sahabis are buried, and it is not because they wanted to keep their burial location secret, but rather because it does not matter.

The other fairy tales, such as her shouting at Abu Bakr (RAA) and holding him by his shirt, is more appropriate to an immoral lady who works in the sex trade than to the daughter of the Prophet (SAW), who would go out of her way so that no one even knew what figure her cloak she used to cover herself had.

The other issues are not even worth poring over, as we already know the level of so-called 'respect' they truly have for the Prophet (SAW) and his daughter (RAA), in spite of their claims to the contrary.

10-05-2011, 12:43 AM	#6
Gcromqgb Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 436 Senior Member	^ Concerning the funeral: The modern Twelver Shia mind cannot understand the issue of women's modesty. This is why you the very religious Shia parties have female MPs making a show of themselves and so forth, in an attempt to show that Twelver Shia principles are compatible with modern-day women's liberation. If this is their way, well then this is their way and religion, and they are free to practice their religion until the Day of Judgment. But they should know that Fatimah (RAA) was so modest that she did not wish for people to even view her burial sheet after she had passed away. So this puts to rest all these stories about her not wanting people to see her after her death. The other issue, of people not knowing where her grave is located is (a) false and (b) even if it were true it makes no difference, since we have no idea where most of the Sahabis are buried, and it is not because they wanted to keep their burial location secret, but rather because it does not matter. The other fairy tales, such as her shouting at Abu Bakr (RAA) and holding him by his shirt, is more appropriate to an immoral lady who works in the sex trade than to the daughter of the Prophet (SAW), who would go out of her way so that no one even knew what figure her cloak she used to cover herself had. The other issues are not even worth poring over, as we already know the level of so-called 'respect' they truly have for the Prophet (SAW) and his daughter (RAA), in spite of their claims to the contrary.
	Quote