As-Salamu 'alaykum, Shaykh Hamza Yusuf wrote, Shaykh Nuh Ha Mim Keller also wrote in his translation Reliance of the Traveller, They may not agree with all of his views, such as the perennial philosophy, but they do not write Nasr and his work off simply because of a few real or perceived errors. Among Muslim scholars and intellectuals in the West (and you can ask just about any of them), Nasr is perhaps the most important writer and speaker to have presented an authentic and penetrating vision of traditional Islam in all of it facets (Law, theology, Sufism, philosophy, science, art, chivalry, history, etc.)...Those who have read his works on Islam and seen how vast his influence has been would be very careful before they criticize him simply for being of Iranian origin or treating the Ahl al-Kitab with a measure of respect. God knows best, Nur Muhammad