DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Ibn Mas'ud(ra) & Loud Zikr: Shaykh Faraz explains.

**tearidrusydet** · 04-17-2011, 07:11 AM

I never knew Shaikh Albani was the sole arbtrater of Haq and batil. Scholar even questioned his scholastic credential in hadith and Fiqh. Are we to accept him over the Salf us Saleh of Jumhur. This blind following of Mr. Albani has to be done away with. As Dr. Ati has nicely put it 'such fatawa' is irrlevent. I wonder who is really irrlevant here - a recent scholar (with questionable grasp of hadith and fiqh) or scholar like Imam Suyuti or Al Dahabi RAH!!!

The Jarah of Al-Haythami and Sayuti here is understandable so i won't take it. Do you agree with everything Imam Al-Dhahabi rahimuhullah deemed correct?

04-17-2011, 07:11 AM	#16
tearidrusydet Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 483 Senior Member	I never knew Shaikh Albani was the sole arbtrater of Haq and batil. Scholar even questioned his scholastic credential in hadith and Fiqh. Are we to accept him over the Salf us Saleh of Jumhur. This blind following of Mr. Albani has to be done away with. As Dr. Ati has nicely put it 'such fatawa' is irrlevent. I wonder who is really irrlevant here - a recent scholar (with questionable grasp of hadith and fiqh) or scholar like Imam Suyuti or Al Dahabi RAH!!! The Jarah of Al-Haythami and Sayuti here is understandable so i won't take it. Do you agree with everything Imam Al-Dhahabi rahimuhullah deemed correct?
	Quote