DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Ibn Mas'ud(ra) & Loud Zikr: Shaykh Faraz explains.

**yarita** · 04-18-2011, 11:05 AM

Dear Brothers & Sisters, Assalaamoalaikum

Group Dhikr (loud of course) IS PERMISSIBLE and there are a lot of blessings in same, whether any Sahabi (ra) spoke against it or whether any Scholar said anything contrary.

Lest someone would come again with the question "Why did the Holy Messenger(SAW) or any of the Sahaba (ra) did not do so?", then may I submit again the following questions that to date have not been replied to, viz:

"Why did the Holy Messenger(SAW) did not do certain things?" and "Why did the Sahabah(ra) not do certain things?" ......... sau like Group Dhikr, since this is the topic under discussion.

Anything is impermissible if and only if same is not in harmony with the principles of ISLAM , as mentioned in a hadith provided by a Brother on some other Thread recently.

Brotherly yours
farook

04-18-2011, 11:05 AM	#29
yarita Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 661 Senior Member	Dear Brothers & Sisters, Assalaamoalaikum Group Dhikr (loud of course) IS PERMISSIBLE and there are a lot of blessings in same, whether any Sahabi (ra) spoke against it or whether any Scholar said anything contrary. Lest someone would come again with the question "Why did the Holy Messenger(SAW) or any of the Sahaba (ra) did not do so?", then may I submit again the following questions that to date have not been replied to, viz: "Why did the Holy Messenger(SAW) did not do certain things?" and "Why did the Sahabah(ra) not do certain things?" ......... sau like Group Dhikr, since this is the topic under discussion. Anything is impermissible if and only if same is not in harmony with the principles of ISLAM , as mentioned in a hadith provided by a Brother on some other Thread recently. Brotherly yours farook
	Quote