DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Ibn Mas'ud(ra) & Loud Zikr: Shaykh Faraz explains.

**shemadagaswer** · 09-02-2011, 05:34 AM

im confused, do deobandis have one position on this issue or is there serious ikhtilaaf? Do any of them say group dhickr is bid'ah and on what grounds?

Also dr ati can you bring a response to the statements abu tamim made on the disparagement of some of the narrators of the hadeeth?

this is an importan tissue for me so would like to get to the bottom of it inshAllah

It's not a simple issue. You'll have to study a bit to gain some clarity. If your read the book whose link I posted, then your confusions will be alleviated to a great extent inshaAllah.

09-02-2011, 05:34 AM	#39
shemadagaswer Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 464 Senior Member	im confused, do deobandis have one position on this issue or is there serious ikhtilaaf? Do any of them say group dhickr is bid'ah and on what grounds? Also dr ati can you bring a response to the statements abu tamim made on the disparagement of some of the narrators of the hadeeth? this is an importan tissue for me so would like to get to the bottom of it inshAllah It's not a simple issue. You'll have to study a bit to gain some clarity. If your read the book whose link I posted, then your confusions will be alleviated to a great extent inshaAllah.
	Quote