DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Read Quran in Arabic (or) Quran in other Languages.

**AntonioMQ** · 03-03-2012, 11:06 AM

He agrees quran was completed in Arabic but he says Arabic is for Arabic peoples and he says what is the use in reading the quran in language which we don't understand, he reads salah also in his own language, He says reward is for reciting quran in own language.

He said me after taking alcohol quran is prohibited on us because we do not have concentration while we read, and for mental also quran is not allowed. So if we read quran in Arabic and we did not understand the meanings of it then what is the difference in between drinker or mental and us?

As brother amr123 has said, stay away from such people. They lack any intelligence if they can claim that it is okay to pray salah in their own language.

The Noble Qur'an is the literal word of the one free from any and all errors, Allah

. The translations he is reading are the literal words of flawed HUMANS who translated the literal words according to their flawed understanding. There even was an English version of the Qur'an some time ago that was translated by a Christian Islamophobe - reading that would turn people away from Islam. So, a translation is nowhere near the authentic thing. One of the biggest reasons that the Bible is considered corrupt is because the originals do not exist. In fact, the New Testament was translated into Hebrew from Greek - and 'Isa

could understand and speak Hebrew but couldn't speak Greek - so how does that work?

Similarly, Rasoolullah

spoke Arabic. Even the Qur'an says that it is in the ARABIC language. To say otherwise is to deny the Qur'an - which is clear kufr.

Also, the prohibition with regards to alcohol mentioned in the Qur'an is of three sorts, depending upon time of revelation - but none of them talk about reciting the Qur'an when drunk. So ask him for his evidence of not being allowed to read the Qur'an when one is drunk.

03-03-2012, 11:06 AM	#7
AntonioMQ Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 545 Senior Member	He agrees quran was completed in Arabic but he says Arabic is for Arabic peoples and he says what is the use in reading the quran in language which we don't understand, he reads salah also in his own language, He says reward is for reciting quran in own language. He said me after taking alcohol quran is prohibited on us because we do not have concentration while we read, and for mental also quran is not allowed. So if we read quran in Arabic and we did not understand the meanings of it then what is the difference in between drinker or mental and us? As brother amr123 has said, stay away from such people. They lack any intelligence if they can claim that it is okay to pray salah in their own language. The Noble Qur'an is the literal word of the one free from any and all errors, Allah . The translations he is reading are the literal words of flawed HUMANS who translated the literal words according to their flawed understanding. There even was an English version of the Qur'an some time ago that was translated by a Christian Islamophobe - reading that would turn people away from Islam. So, a translation is nowhere near the authentic thing. One of the biggest reasons that the Bible is considered corrupt is because the originals do not exist. In fact, the New Testament was translated into Hebrew from Greek - and 'Isa could understand and speak Hebrew but couldn't speak Greek - so how does that work? Similarly, Rasoolullah spoke Arabic. Even the Qur'an says that it is in the ARABIC language. To say otherwise is to deny the Qur'an - which is clear kufr. Also, the prohibition with regards to alcohol mentioned in the Qur'an is of three sorts, depending upon time of revelation - but none of them talk about reciting the Qur'an when drunk. So ask him for his evidence of not being allowed to read the Qur'an when one is drunk.
	Quote