DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Saduyre9de** · 02-27-2011, 01:51 AM

Yes, he has passed away but he was the head of the Wahhabiyya in Damascus. He was once accused of tampering with the words of Imam al-Nawawi in his Kitab al Adhkar, but when he was asked directly by Shaykh Mahmud Saeed Mamduh if he had done this - al-Arna'ut replied by blaiming the Riyadh based Wahhabi printers for tampering with it instead! Arna'uts hand written reply is printed in the back of Shaykh Mahmud' book on Tawassul: Raf al-Minara (which refuted most of the contemporary Wahhabi lies on this issue) in nearly 400 pages.

Interesting enough. I don't see the reason for doubting his statement. According to Shaykh Al-Arna'ut (rah) he had written his notes on the text which were removed by the publisher or whosoever. He mentioned that he had written his analysis on the narration of Al-Utbi which were removed. Mahmud Sa'eed asked the son of Shaykh Abdul Qaadir and he denied such distortion from his father side. All this is present in Rafa' Al-Manarah (73-75). Shaykh Abdul Qaadir had written his defense before it was inquired by Mahmud Sa'eed. He used to send it to whosoever inquired it from him.
See this:
http://saaid.net/Warathah/1/alarnaut.htm#_Toc70769592

02-27-2011, 01:51 AM	#11
Saduyre9de Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 493 Senior Member	Yes, he has passed away but he was the head of the Wahhabiyya in Damascus. He was once accused of tampering with the words of Imam al-Nawawi in his Kitab al Adhkar, but when he was asked directly by Shaykh Mahmud Saeed Mamduh if he had done this - al-Arna'ut replied by blaiming the Riyadh based Wahhabi printers for tampering with it instead! Arna'uts hand written reply is printed in the back of Shaykh Mahmud' book on Tawassul: Raf al-Minara (which refuted most of the contemporary Wahhabi lies on this issue) in nearly 400 pages. Interesting enough. I don't see the reason for doubting his statement. According to Shaykh Al-Arna'ut (rah) he had written his notes on the text which were removed by the publisher or whosoever. He mentioned that he had written his analysis on the narration of Al-Utbi which were removed. Mahmud Sa'eed asked the son of Shaykh Abdul Qaadir and he denied such distortion from his father side. All this is present in Rafa' Al-Manarah (73-75). Shaykh Abdul Qaadir had written his defense before it was inquired by Mahmud Sa'eed. He used to send it to whosoever inquired it from him. See this: http://saaid.net/Warathah/1/alarnaut.htm#_Toc70769592
	Quote