DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**MiniBoy** · 02-27-2011, 02:01 AM

Interesting enough. I don't see the reason for doubting his statement. According to Shaykh Al-Arna'ut (rah) he had written his notes on the text which were removed by the publisher or whosoever. He mentioned that he had written his analysis on the narration of Al-Utbi which were removed. Mahmud Sa'eed asked the son of Shaykh Abdul Qaadir and he denied such distortion from his father side. All this is present in Rafa' Al-Manarah (73-75). Shaykh Abdul Qaadir had written his defense before it was inquired by Mahmud Sa'eed. He used to send it to whosoever inquired it from him.
See this:
http://saaid.net/Warathah/1/alarnaut.htm#_Toc70769592

how is Mahmood Saeed Mamduh doing these days ? Another Habib Hasan Ali Saqqaf in making ? how does that sound ? so Habib Hasan Ali Saqqaf head of which group and Mahmood Saeed Mamduh head of which group ? May be a little reminder about hadith of jabir on noor al-nabi

rings a bell about tampering and publishing fabrications ?

Yes, he has passed away but he was the head of the Wahhabiyya in Damascus.

so, when the Ahbash / Habashis came to kill Abdal Qadir Arnaut, so does it mean Asharites wanted to assassinate wahhabis ?

muslims should be just and balanced. bigotry and tas'sub should be rejected.

02-27-2011, 02:01 AM	#12
MiniBoy Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 495 Senior Member	Interesting enough. I don't see the reason for doubting his statement. According to Shaykh Al-Arna'ut (rah) he had written his notes on the text which were removed by the publisher or whosoever. He mentioned that he had written his analysis on the narration of Al-Utbi which were removed. Mahmud Sa'eed asked the son of Shaykh Abdul Qaadir and he denied such distortion from his father side. All this is present in Rafa' Al-Manarah (73-75). Shaykh Abdul Qaadir had written his defense before it was inquired by Mahmud Sa'eed. He used to send it to whosoever inquired it from him. See this: http://saaid.net/Warathah/1/alarnaut.htm#_Toc70769592 how is Mahmood Saeed Mamduh doing these days ? Another Habib Hasan Ali Saqqaf in making ? how does that sound ? so Habib Hasan Ali Saqqaf head of which group and Mahmood Saeed Mamduh head of which group ? May be a little reminder about hadith of jabir on noor al-nabi rings a bell about tampering and publishing fabrications ? Yes, he has passed away but he was the head of the Wahhabiyya in Damascus. so, when the Ahbash / Habashis came to kill Abdal Qadir Arnaut, so does it mean Asharites wanted to assassinate wahhabis ? muslims should be just and balanced. bigotry and tas'sub should be rejected.
	Quote