DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - An Islamic View of Gog and Magog in the Modern Age

**budumol** · 01-30-2009, 06:14 PM

Likewise it is very shortsighted to criticise a work without studying it

Goblins and Dwarfs brother? A two hundred odd page thesis vs Goblins and Dwarfs?!?

I think you should perhaps take the time to read the book, all your doubts have been dealt with as you can see from the table of contents.

ma'asalaamah,

salam
he did state why it is inaccurate.
we go by our ahadith and what the ulema of ahl al-sunna say.

some modernists also say dajjal doesn't need to be an individual but can be the state of israel for example

it's interesting that some of the orthodox jews who have been deceived about this state also say their messiah (who is supposed to gather them in palestine) is also metaphorical and the coming of the messiah has been fulfilled with the creation of israel.
the non-zionist jews reject that and say israel is a curse on the jews and a deception and that they should still be in exile until God sends the messiah.

the sunni position is clear - yajuj and majuj are yet to come - may Allah save us from them.

01-30-2009, 06:14 PM	#6
budumol Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 299 Senior Member	Likewise it is very shortsighted to criticise a work without studying it Goblins and Dwarfs brother? A two hundred odd page thesis vs Goblins and Dwarfs?!? I think you should perhaps take the time to read the book, all your doubts have been dealt with as you can see from the table of contents. ma'asalaamah, salam he did state why it is inaccurate. we go by our ahadith and what the ulema of ahl al-sunna say. some modernists also say dajjal doesn't need to be an individual but can be the state of israel for example it's interesting that some of the orthodox jews who have been deceived about this state also say their messiah (who is supposed to gather them in palestine) is also metaphorical and the coming of the messiah has been fulfilled with the creation of israel. the non-zionist jews reject that and say israel is a curse on the jews and a deception and that they should still be in exile until God sends the messiah. the sunni position is clear - yajuj and majuj are yet to come - may Allah save us from them.
	Quote