DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**PetraCromlich** · 02-04-2012, 03:01 PM

Because almost all the ulema are men and dont care women. In thier fiqhi understanding men 'own' women and thus use and throw as they wish. Notice how legally they favour men and urge them only morally to not to do divorce in ths manner. A man can in a fit of anger or in a drunken state can divorce his wife instaneously.

In ahl - hadith school three talaqs are counted as one and hence more compassionate in this regard.

What? No they have not, Ghair Muqalladeen (aka ahl e hadith or whatever you like to disguise them as) had a huge rift on this issue and the Saudia Ulama had gone against Ibn Taymiyyah on this issue and did not find his opinion to be solid. There is a book called Asr-e-Haazir Ke Paichida Masail Aur Unka Hal. Here is the copy of the citation from it, sorry for the bad copy:

http://theredsulphur.wordpress.com/2...hair-muqallid/

Though ghair muqallideen hazraat always give citation from Saudi Ulama on issues, but for some strange reason on this issue of talaaq they completely ignore the opinion of the 17 akaabir ulama of Saudia. I dont know why...

02-04-2012, 03:01 PM	#20
PetraCromlich Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 467 Senior Member	Because almost all the ulema are men and dont care women. In thier fiqhi understanding men 'own' women and thus use and throw as they wish. Notice how legally they favour men and urge them only morally to not to do divorce in ths manner. A man can in a fit of anger or in a drunken state can divorce his wife instaneously. In ahl - hadith school three talaqs are counted as one and hence more compassionate in this regard. What? No they have not, Ghair Muqalladeen (aka ahl e hadith or whatever you like to disguise them as) had a huge rift on this issue and the Saudia Ulama had gone against Ibn Taymiyyah on this issue and did not find his opinion to be solid. There is a book called Asr-e-Haazir Ke Paichida Masail Aur Unka Hal. Here is the copy of the citation from it, sorry for the bad copy: http://theredsulphur.wordpress.com/2...hair-muqallid/ Though ghair muqallideen hazraat always give citation from Saudi Ulama on issues, but for some strange reason on this issue of talaaq they completely ignore the opinion of the 17 akaabir ulama of Saudia. I dont know why...
	Quote