DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**klubneras** · 01-28-2012, 09:28 AM

Does a person have to follow a madhab? His answers are backed up my quran and hadith, how can they be wrong?

There is a methodology (usool) to derive Fatwas from Quran and hadith. Not everyone can derive rulings by just quoting the text. Fiqh is a very complicated matter. This is not my own opinion. Look what Maulana Abuhajira posted about the link of islamqa:

http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...l=1#post250893

Authenticity in Fiqh is not restricted to presentation of the Hadith as a proof, rather presenting the understanding of that hadith from the sahaba, tabi'i etc. Most of Salafi rulings are from Zahir of the texts which can be wrong at times.

I do not think that the brother meant unauthentic as in using fabrications..rather unauthentic as in the deductions being contrary to the authentically established opinions within Fiqh. (at times i.e)

01-28-2012, 09:28 AM	#15
klubneras Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 507 Senior Member	Does a person have to follow a madhab? His answers are backed up my quran and hadith, how can they be wrong? There is a methodology (usool) to derive Fatwas from Quran and hadith. Not everyone can derive rulings by just quoting the text. Fiqh is a very complicated matter. This is not my own opinion. Look what Maulana Abuhajira posted about the link of islamqa: http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...l=1#post250893 Authenticity in Fiqh is not restricted to presentation of the Hadith as a proof, rather presenting the understanding of that hadith from the sahaba, tabi'i etc. Most of Salafi rulings are from Zahir of the texts which can be wrong at times. I do not think that the brother meant unauthentic as in using fabrications..rather unauthentic as in the deductions being contrary to the authentically established opinions within Fiqh. (at times i.e)
	Quote