DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Qasidah Burda- Shirk?

**fabrizioitwloch** · 04-25-2009, 06:52 AM

Salam,

Why have you only focus on one bayt? Why dont you explain this : ومن علومك علم اللوح والقلم

Is that not ghulow?

The reason I've only focused on one bayt is because:

(a) I simply didn't have time to explain all the questionable bayts

(b) My purpose was not to exhaustively cover all the bayts. I'm just pointing out the fallacious nature of the objections to Qasidah Burdah and that it's not always what it seems at face value.

And coming back to the point, if I'm wrong in only focusing on one bayt, the least you can do is accept that the Salafi objections to the bayt I discussed may not be as strong as they first seem.

Otherwise, if I go on to explaining the bayt which you've quoted, I don't want you conveniently skipping to next bayt saying, "Why are you only focusing on TWO bayts?"

04-25-2009, 06:52 AM	#28
fabrizioitwloch Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 540 Senior Member	Salam, Why have you only focus on one bayt? Why dont you explain this : ومن علومك علم اللوح والقلم Is that not ghulow? The reason I've only focused on one bayt is because: (a) I simply didn't have time to explain all the questionable bayts (b) My purpose was not to exhaustively cover all the bayts. I'm just pointing out the fallacious nature of the objections to Qasidah Burdah and that it's not always what it seems at face value. And coming back to the point, if I'm wrong in only focusing on one bayt, the least you can do is accept that the Salafi objections to the bayt I discussed may not be as strong as they first seem. Otherwise, if I go on to explaining the bayt which you've quoted, I don't want you conveniently skipping to next bayt saying, "Why are you only focusing on TWO bayts?"
	Quote