View Single Post
Old 12-31-2011, 09:55 AM   #17
herawaq

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
563
Senior Member
Default
I had read a short article on history of Ahl Hadeeth or had listened to a lecture on, how it started, where it started etc. but it was a long time ago when I didn't know anything about them. I don't remember its name.
Usually when scholars say something, it isn't just a random thing. They have their reasons and daleel.

When Ghulam Ahmed Qadiani started his kufr, the ulama had told people that he was a british agent, but just like nowadays, the ulama were mocked for having conspiracy theories. But now everyone knows the truth.

Similarly, the case with Abdullah bin Saba, the father of Shiaism, when ulama called him Munafiq Jew, the people laughed and mocked the ulama about having conspiracy theories. But now everyone agrees.

And the list goes on...

So rather than just brushing aside the claim of the ulama, we should help them with their research to prove their points. There would be much reward for such people, who respect the ulama and help them.
aoa,
the deobandis and barelvis are termed agents of british too. do we not brush that aside without proof?
all i asked is that if there is verifiable proof then please bring it.
and ahle hadith dont comprise a sect. some dont follow scholars at all and do their own ijtihad. and the ghair muqallids of india and arabia are vastly different. we cant just group them together.
its like the scholars of hijaz once termed deobandis and barelvis to be the same. lack of knowledge and miscommunication. and they were ulema too

the snide hints about british agents may be one of the biggest obstacles an ahle hadith may face in becoming muqallid. its best we shed aside things w/o proof.

i dont disrespect ulema. but i dont believe them to be infallible and i dont really trust an alim unless he can show proof in his words and writings. many wrongs in islamic world are because of blind following.

and also it is wrong to compare ahle hadith with kuffar and munafiqeen.
herawaq is offline


 

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:06 PM.
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Design & Developed by Amodity.com
Copyright© Amodity