DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Why has Ammar (son of Ml. Zahid ur Rashidi) not been refuted?

**attishina** · 05-30-2010, 11:31 AM

Asslam-o-Alaikum,

I heard about one of the son of Maulana Zahid ur Rasheedi had accepted the religion of Javaid Ahmad Ghamdi (a Hadeeth Rejector). but now I was reading a book of Maulana Muhammad Rafiq "Javed Ghamdi aur Inkar-e-Hadeeth" in which he said that Maulana Zahid ur Rasheedi shouldn't show "Maslihat" on Javaid Ahmad Ghamdi and refute him openly.

after that i asked a few students from a madrassa about Ammar , they told me he has really accepted ghamdi religion and have also written some books. and he also calls himself modern. today I went through the web and found that its true , he really has accepted ghamdi and is writting for him. in his Monthly Ashraaq. he has been mentioned on ghamdi's site and even asnwered allegations on ghamdi on some sites.

I really feel bad to know that he has left true faith. but I feel more bad to know that Ammar is still writing in Muslim magazines.

Why hasn't Maulana Zahid ur Rasheedi refuted Ghamdi openly , why has he not broken relation with Ammar for accepting Ghamdi religion. Why is Ammar not openly refuted by Ulema.

Please guide me .

05-30-2010, 11:31 AM	#1
attishina Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 823 Senior Member	Why has Ammar (son of Ml. Zahid ur Rashidi) not been refuted? Asslam-o-Alaikum, I heard about one of the son of Maulana Zahid ur Rasheedi had accepted the religion of Javaid Ahmad Ghamdi (a Hadeeth Rejector). but now I was reading a book of Maulana Muhammad Rafiq "Javed Ghamdi aur Inkar-e-Hadeeth" in which he said that Maulana Zahid ur Rasheedi shouldn't show "Maslihat" on Javaid Ahmad Ghamdi and refute him openly. after that i asked a few students from a madrassa about Ammar , they told me he has really accepted ghamdi religion and have also written some books. and he also calls himself modern. today I went through the web and found that its true , he really has accepted ghamdi and is writting for him. in his Monthly Ashraaq. he has been mentioned on ghamdi's site and even asnwered allegations on ghamdi on some sites. I really feel bad to know that he has left true faith. but I feel more bad to know that Ammar is still writing in Muslim magazines. Why hasn't Maulana Zahid ur Rasheedi refuted Ghamdi openly , why has he not broken relation with Ammar for accepting Ghamdi religion. Why is Ammar not openly refuted by Ulema. Please guide me .
	Quote