DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Allegation on Aamale Qur'ani By Maulana Ashraf ALi thanwi

**24MurinivaMak** · 01-02-2012, 05:34 PM

IT IS MENTIONED IN AAMAAL-E-QURANI,PAGE 134 BY MAULANA ASHRAF ALI THANWI(PUBLISHED BY JASIM BOOK DEPOT,URDU BAZAR JAMA MASJID DELHI)THAT IF A WOMAN HAS EXCESSIVE MENSTRUAL BLEEDING,THE VERSE(SURAH AL-IMRAN: 3:44) SHOULD BE WRITTEN ON THREE DIFFERENT PIECES OF PAPER,ONE TIED ON HER RIGHT AND THE OTHER ON HER LEFT AND THE THIRD PIECE OF PAPER WITH THE QURAANIC VERSE TO BE HUNG BELOW THE NAVAL.THIS VERSE OF THE QURAN,"MOHAMMED(SALLALLAHU ALAIHE WA SALLAM)IS NO MORE THAN A MESSENGER,AND INDEED (MANY)MESSENGERS HAVE PASSED AWAY BEFORE HIM.IF HE DIES OR IS KILLED .WILL YOU THEN TURN ON YOUR HEELS (AS DISBELIEVERS)AND HE WHO TURNS BACK ON HIS HELLS,NOT THE LEAST HARM WILL HE DO TO ALLAH,AND ALLAH WILL GIVE REWARD TO THOSE WHO ARE GRATEFUL"(SURAH AL-IMRAN:3:144)

I have just heard this being quoted by Meraj Rubani in his noor tv lecture entitled jinnat aur uski haqeeqat (part 3 on youtube). He is implying that this is extremely disgraceful advice - that of hanging verses of the Quran beteen a woman's legs - this is what he says below the navel means. He is mocking Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi and implies he is "selling the Quran" and gave this example saying it is corrupt and wrong to follow these kind of advices. I did not feel comfortable with how he was going on and stopped listening and do not intend to finish listening to the series, and although I officially do not follow any particular scholars, I do feel inclined to Deobandi scholars so I suppose I am seeking aome reassurance for the above.

Also what does mujarrib amal mean? (post no.2)

the written verse is not kept directly but folded and tied in cloth so it is no longer visible and this prevents any disrespect. And below the navel is a wide area, not necessarily reaching between the legs, It can be just below the umblicus- on the abdomen. So, what Hazrat Thanwi RA wrote is perfectly ok according to fiqh and books of previous Imams on Taweez and Ruqya.
Only a deviant thinks about that area (between the legs) always.

01-02-2012, 05:34 PM	#10
24MurinivaMak Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 468 Senior Member	IT IS MENTIONED IN AAMAAL-E-QURANI,PAGE 134 BY MAULANA ASHRAF ALI THANWI(PUBLISHED BY JASIM BOOK DEPOT,URDU BAZAR JAMA MASJID DELHI)THAT IF A WOMAN HAS EXCESSIVE MENSTRUAL BLEEDING,THE VERSE(SURAH AL-IMRAN: 3:44) SHOULD BE WRITTEN ON THREE DIFFERENT PIECES OF PAPER,ONE TIED ON HER RIGHT AND THE OTHER ON HER LEFT AND THE THIRD PIECE OF PAPER WITH THE QURAANIC VERSE TO BE HUNG BELOW THE NAVAL.THIS VERSE OF THE QURAN,"MOHAMMED(SALLALLAHU ALAIHE WA SALLAM)IS NO MORE THAN A MESSENGER,AND INDEED (MANY)MESSENGERS HAVE PASSED AWAY BEFORE HIM.IF HE DIES OR IS KILLED .WILL YOU THEN TURN ON YOUR HEELS (AS DISBELIEVERS)AND HE WHO TURNS BACK ON HIS HELLS,NOT THE LEAST HARM WILL HE DO TO ALLAH,AND ALLAH WILL GIVE REWARD TO THOSE WHO ARE GRATEFUL"(SURAH AL-IMRAN:3:144) I have just heard this being quoted by Meraj Rubani in his noor tv lecture entitled jinnat aur uski haqeeqat (part 3 on youtube). He is implying that this is extremely disgraceful advice - that of hanging verses of the Quran beteen a woman's legs - this is what he says below the navel means. He is mocking Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi and implies he is "selling the Quran" and gave this example saying it is corrupt and wrong to follow these kind of advices. I did not feel comfortable with how he was going on and stopped listening and do not intend to finish listening to the series, and although I officially do not follow any particular scholars, I do feel inclined to Deobandi scholars so I suppose I am seeking aome reassurance for the above. Also what does mujarrib amal mean? (post no.2) the written verse is not kept directly but folded and tied in cloth so it is no longer visible and this prevents any disrespect. And below the navel is a wide area, not necessarily reaching between the legs, It can be just below the umblicus- on the abdomen. So, what Hazrat Thanwi RA wrote is perfectly ok according to fiqh and books of previous Imams on Taweez and Ruqya. Only a deviant thinks about that area (between the legs) always.
	Quote