DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Lessons based on the Hanbali text al-Umdah

**cliceperperIa** · 10-15-2009, 11:52 PM

I agree.

What I get from a few lessons I browsed through is that Daleel of the 4 madhahib is presented and then it seems a fifth point of view is presented which suggests a safe approach to follow. In short what is believed to be the strongest evidence or a combination of the evidences to come up to a position. This methodology is very similar to the gayr muqallid methodology. Maybe brother ibnfarooq can shed light on this.

I just deleted my last post, as I don't want to start another flamewar. Just forget my question.

@hyneln2000, with all due respect but I think it is common amongst all scholars that they believe one position/opinion/view to be the strongest and others to be weak/er.

We should have a good opinion of brother ibnfarooq.

10-15-2009, 11:52 PM	#6
cliceperperIa Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 403 Senior Member	I agree. What I get from a few lessons I browsed through is that Daleel of the 4 madhahib is presented and then it seems a fifth point of view is presented which suggests a safe approach to follow. In short what is believed to be the strongest evidence or a combination of the evidences to come up to a position. This methodology is very similar to the gayr muqallid methodology. Maybe brother ibnfarooq can shed light on this. I just deleted my last post, as I don't want to start another flamewar. Just forget my question. @hyneln2000, with all due respect but I think it is common amongst all scholars that they believe one position/opinion/view to be the strongest and others to be weak/er. We should have a good opinion of brother ibnfarooq.
	Quote