View Single Post
Old 12-12-2011, 08:30 AM   #28
bestworkother

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
505
Senior Member
Default
From what I feel, overall, Hanafi is the strictest and Shafi is the easiest:
1) You can only pray the fardh and not every pray anything else (including witr) - no problem
2) no kaffarah for eating intentionally
3) no hurme musahharat
4) plucking of eyebrows allowed
5) shaving the beard allowed
6) pants below the ankles allowed
7) combining salat in journey allowed without any excuse
8) i heard combining salat during rain also allowed
9) no zakat on gold/silver jewellery
10) bismillah not a requirement for slaughter
11) it seems niqab not required either
12) udhiya/qurbani not wajib
13) witr not wajib
14) haram fantasizing about opposite gender not sinful even while having intimate relations
15) all seafood allowed

Catch all: if anything is stricter compared to other madhabs, one can follow the other madhab by doing mix-and-match without any need/excuse - absolutely no problem - this is what has been relayed to me reliably from Moulana Taha Karan

I personally do not recall encountering any issue where the Shafis did not opt for another less reliable position or position from another madhab when their opinion was strict, unless the easier opinion is an opinion held by the salafis.
brother,

better to check your points with shafii scholars. "I heard" is not strong enough to base a decision on. I know for sure points no.4,9 & 10 are wrong. And I don't quite understand what do you mean as "haram" but not "sinful" on number 14? Also no. 7 can only be done with certain conditions are met.

Actually, a few of the stuffs you mentioned are also makruh, like no. 6.

My advice, It's better to check with a shafii scholar.

Allah Knows best.
bestworkother is offline


 

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:30 AM.
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Design & Developed by Amodity.com
Copyright© Amodity