DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - I recieved this message from hadith denier.

**smokeberly** · 11-28-2011, 07:45 AM

You need not worry. Hadiths are works of man, so they are not perfect. Unless you consider that hadith collectors were DIVINE. [/B]

hence there's a grading system for every hadith collected. If you think collecting hadith is just that, to write down the said hadith in a book, then anyone can be a hadith collector/grader. Knowing that the hadith collectors and the people responsible for the chains of the narrations were not infallible reinforced the need to have a sound and clear grading system that encompass the hadith, the people and the environment to ensure that only the authentic hadiths can be used as a source of reference.

To blatantly disregard the careful work of the past alims without any justifications and in-depth knowledge of the system itself is already an insult to anyone's intelligence, let alone to deny the importance of such system objectively.

11-28-2011, 07:45 AM	#5
smokeberly Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 392 Senior Member	You need not worry. Hadiths are works of man, so they are not perfect. Unless you consider that hadith collectors were DIVINE. [/B] hence there's a grading system for every hadith collected. If you think collecting hadith is just that, to write down the said hadith in a book, then anyone can be a hadith collector/grader. Knowing that the hadith collectors and the people responsible for the chains of the narrations were not infallible reinforced the need to have a sound and clear grading system that encompass the hadith, the people and the environment to ensure that only the authentic hadiths can be used as a source of reference. To blatantly disregard the careful work of the past alims without any justifications and in-depth knowledge of the system itself is already an insult to anyone's intelligence, let alone to deny the importance of such system objectively.
	Quote