DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**freevideom** · 02-14-2011, 01:12 AM

assalam o alikom warahmatullahi wabarakatuh!

i would like to tell you that i am a Muslim, hanfi and Sunni i would like to know Sunni hanfi replies

as we know that celebrating eid milad un nabi is wrong its bidah! and many of us celebrate it our Prophet (SAW ) never celebrated neither did the companions.. nor the khulfa e rashideen.. neither our islamic scholors.. we know its wrong!
buw i just rad that people who say prayers and naats they do get SAWAB (good deeds) they do get blessings.. but i also know that celebrating bidah is wrong.. so now em confused..
please help me

will they get blessing for celebrating bid ah? will they?

and also one of my friend also celebrates it. I told her its bidah! its wrong.. i said you should ask some scholar but she kept on refusing! i said i may ot be able to convince u but she's so stubborn about that! tell me how could i tell her that its wrong??

kindly reply fast

Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu

It's not my opinion. I've heard from scholars:

- There is Ikhtilaf about Prophet

's birthday. There's no consensus about the date.

- But Prophet

's date of passing away is obvious.

- Sahabah

got the greatest shock in their lives when Prophet

passed away. They knew about Prophet

's date of birth very well, but they never celebrated it.

- As a muslim everyone should possess the greatest affection and love for Prophet

and hence how it's possible to express happiness instead of mourning?

We should ponder about those points.

02-14-2011, 01:12 AM	#7
freevideom Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 387 Senior Member	assalam o alikom warahmatullahi wabarakatuh! i would like to tell you that i am a Muslim, hanfi and Sunni i would like to know Sunni hanfi replies as we know that celebrating eid milad un nabi is wrong its bidah! and many of us celebrate it our Prophet (SAW ) never celebrated neither did the companions.. nor the khulfa e rashideen.. neither our islamic scholors.. we know its wrong! buw i just rad that people who say prayers and naats they do get SAWAB (good deeds) they do get blessings.. but i also know that celebrating bidah is wrong.. so now em confused.. please help me will they get blessing for celebrating bid ah? will they? and also one of my friend also celebrates it. I told her its bidah! its wrong.. i said you should ask some scholar but she kept on refusing! i said i may ot be able to convince u but she's so stubborn about that! tell me how could i tell her that its wrong?? kindly reply fast Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu It's not my opinion. I've heard from scholars: - There is Ikhtilaf about Prophet 's birthday. There's no consensus about the date. - But Prophet 's date of passing away is obvious. - Sahabah got the greatest shock in their lives when Prophet passed away. They knew about Prophet 's date of birth very well, but they never celebrated it. - As a muslim everyone should possess the greatest affection and love for Prophet and hence how it's possible to express happiness instead of mourning? We should ponder about those points.
	Quote