DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Meerenuch** · 08-07-2011, 03:17 PM

Assalamu alaykum

Doctor sahib:

Some time back you objected to south African scholar giving fatwah on tahreek-taaleebaan Pak. Similarly sitting in Pak you cannot get the ground situation in India.

One thing I can say Shariah is safer in India than Pak under the scholarship of deoband.

You speak of khilaafath in India, where is khilaafath in our own house, our markets, our marriages etc. we boast of bringing khilafat in whole India.

Ramadan Mubarik Ya Akhi Ahmed Sharif.

Brother I am not giving any Fatwa. I am just sharing my observations which unlike a Fatwa are not binding upon anyone. The impression i get is that, let alone a struggle for caliphate , India is deprived of vocal Ulemas even , except for Maulana Anzar Shah . The Indian Muslims mostly keep on quoting Pakistani Ulema. If you ask me , i have not heard of Indian Ulema except for three or four may be. It seems that Islam in India has made a secret compromise with the secular face of Indian government and has become an integral homogenous part of it. Correct me if i am wrong please.

08-07-2011, 03:17 PM	#20
Meerenuch Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 363 Senior Member	Assalamu alaykum Doctor sahib: Some time back you objected to south African scholar giving fatwah on tahreek-taaleebaan Pak. Similarly sitting in Pak you cannot get the ground situation in India. One thing I can say Shariah is safer in India than Pak under the scholarship of deoband. You speak of khilaafath in India, where is khilaafath in our own house, our markets, our marriages etc. we boast of bringing khilafat in whole India. Ramadan Mubarik Ya Akhi Ahmed Sharif. Brother I am not giving any Fatwa. I am just sharing my observations which unlike a Fatwa are not binding upon anyone. The impression i get is that, let alone a struggle for caliphate , India is deprived of vocal Ulemas even , except for Maulana Anzar Shah . The Indian Muslims mostly keep on quoting Pakistani Ulema. If you ask me , i have not heard of Indian Ulema except for three or four may be. It seems that Islam in India has made a secret compromise with the secular face of Indian government and has become an integral homogenous part of it. Correct me if i am wrong please.
	Quote