[elapicearpisp]

This hadith is is not accepted,Idk if it's da'eef or hasan. It also contradicts other strong ahadith. I'm pretty sure that there is some issue with the transmission of this hadith or its matn.

Also it should be remembered that the holy prophet SAW was the best of mankind,a man getting angry and cursing an orphan girl does not befit the status of Muhammad SAW.

Imam bukhari r.a. did not include this narration in his sahih,while not being criteria for something of Imam muslim's compilations to be correct,it usually confirms it more strongly.



Also in my opinion Imam Muslim r.a. included this hadith to enforce the principle that the prophet SAW was able to lose his anger and curse. This was done in order to explain the hadith of muawiyah r.a. being cursed by the prophet by saying "may allah not fill his belly".

He included all of these ahadith under the chapter heading of people being cursed unjustly by the prophet SAW ,which I do not accept from Imam Muslim.

The prophet SAW did not curse anyone unjustly or out of anger unjustly,and that these ahadith were brought by Imam muslim r.a. to explain the hadith of muawiyah r.a.

Either Imam Muslim r.a. made a mistake,or the prophet SAW was cursed people unjustly out of anger.

I take the first as this hadith contradicts stronger ahadith,and in usool al hadith and fiqh if ahaadith contradict we take amal and belief on the stronger one.


Wallahu 3alam.