DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Hadith in Sahih Muslim, did the prophet curse an orphan girl ? Meaning of this hadith

**elapicearpisp** · 11-22-2011, 02:36 PM

Even if our beloved Rasoolullah did curse an orphan girl there will be very correct reasons for it. Remember in Suratul Kahf when Musa (as) was with Khidr (as), Khidr (as) killed a small boy and it alarmed Musa (as). But later Khidr (as) gave the correct reason for it, since the boy was born a kafir and the justification for doing so.

You have a good point.

However the hadith mentions that the prophet SAW cursed the girl when she didn't deserve it,and thus Allah SWT rewarded the cursed by re compensation.

Thus the curse was done unjustly according to the narration.

It should also be remembered that this is only one ahad hadith,and in matters of belief these type ahadith do not always fit the criteria of accepting it as apart of aqeeda. (This is an issue of belief).

11-22-2011, 02:36 PM	#14
elapicearpisp Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 417 Senior Member	Even if our beloved Rasoolullah did curse an orphan girl there will be very correct reasons for it. Remember in Suratul Kahf when Musa (as) was with Khidr (as), Khidr (as) killed a small boy and it alarmed Musa (as). But later Khidr (as) gave the correct reason for it, since the boy was born a kafir and the justification for doing so. You have a good point. However the hadith mentions that the prophet SAW cursed the girl when she didn't deserve it,and thus Allah SWT rewarded the cursed by re compensation. Thus the curse was done unjustly according to the narration. It should also be remembered that this is only one ahad hadith,and in matters of belief these type ahadith do not always fit the criteria of accepting it as apart of aqeeda. (This is an issue of belief).
	Quote