DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Xiciljed** · 11-24-2011, 01:07 PM

brothers and sisters,

I recently met a couple of "practicing muslims" who lie and cheat, for example make false documents or lie to someone/government, in order to get a job or get something that will bring opportunities to make money...so that they could help the poor muslims back home. I know that lying in general is prohibited. But is it justified if the intention is greater good?

I have also seen that such people are usually successful in what they set out to achieve, whereas the ones who are honest and sincere face a lot of troubles. I cannot help but see it as injustice, sometimes I wonder why Allah swt helps them succeed? Is it because they are right? If they wrong then why does everything fall in place so well? And will they get the rewards for helping those in need?

for your help.

still lying is prohibited..

There are three types of people asking Allah(swt).

1)When they raise their hands for asking something, before saying something Allah(swt) tells the angels to grant them whatever they ask.Why? Because Allah(swt) is angry with them n doesnt like to hear their voice.
2) They ask Allah(swt) their needs.Allah listens to them n they granted what they asked for.
3)They ask Allah(swt) their needs, Allah(swt) tells the angels to grant them some n leave some ungranted. When angels ask oh Allah(swt), they has been asking this from such n such time n they is a very mutaaqi people.Why dont u grant them? Allah(swt) says that i like their voice( n i want them to ask me again n again.If i grant them evrything,they may stop asking.

11-24-2011, 01:07 PM	#3
Xiciljed Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 433 Senior Member	brothers and sisters, I recently met a couple of "practicing muslims" who lie and cheat, for example make false documents or lie to someone/government, in order to get a job or get something that will bring opportunities to make money...so that they could help the poor muslims back home. I know that lying in general is prohibited. But is it justified if the intention is greater good? I have also seen that such people are usually successful in what they set out to achieve, whereas the ones who are honest and sincere face a lot of troubles. I cannot help but see it as injustice, sometimes I wonder why Allah swt helps them succeed? Is it because they are right? If they wrong then why does everything fall in place so well? And will they get the rewards for helping those in need? for your help. still lying is prohibited.. There are three types of people asking Allah(swt). 1)When they raise their hands for asking something, before saying something Allah(swt) tells the angels to grant them whatever they ask.Why? Because Allah(swt) is angry with them n doesnt like to hear their voice. 2) They ask Allah(swt) their needs.Allah listens to them n they granted what they asked for. 3)They ask Allah(swt) their needs, Allah(swt) tells the angels to grant them some n leave some ungranted. When angels ask oh Allah(swt), they has been asking this from such n such time n they is a very mutaaqi people.Why dont u grant them? Allah(swt) says that i like their voice( n i want them to ask me again n again.If i grant them evrything,they may stop asking.
	Quote