DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**agiopwer** · 11-23-2011, 07:37 AM

Bro--------Are you sure Jesus was a Jew? Then the question arises who Crucified him according to Bible, JEWS or CHRITIANS? Does the QURAN tells us he (pbuh) was a JEW?

During the Jesus'

life on earth there was no such thing as a "christian" - He was never crucified, and if someone was crucified in his place is something we do not know for sure - if someone was crucified, they would have been crucified by both jews and pagan romans. Remember, Jesus

was a nabi sent to the the jews of his time who had strayed away from the path of Allah - shortly before his birth the Pharisees got together and decided that Judaism would transform from a Propheticly led religion to a Rabinnacly led religion - they then wrote the Talmud. So Jesus

was raised in a Talmudic Jewish society, unlike previous anbiya sent to Bani Israel. His message to the Jews at that time was basicly to abandon the man made laws of the Talmud. One law jews did not abandon was circumcision - and no uncircumcised person could be counted as a jew or set foot in the temple - Jesus

was considered by the Jews, including Jewish historian Josephus to be "an important Rabbi" - so he was considered a Jew by the Jews, and one way one is confirmed as a jew in talmudic judaism is to have a Rabbi perform a ritual circumcission and confirm the childs Jewish heritage.

So even though the Quran and hadeeth do not mention it, the other evidence surrounding his life leads us to deduce that Jesus

Jewishness was confirmed, and to be confirmed a Jew, one must be circumcised.

11-23-2011, 07:37 AM	#8
agiopwer Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 441 Senior Member	Bro--------Are you sure Jesus was a Jew? Then the question arises who Crucified him according to Bible, JEWS or CHRITIANS? Does the QURAN tells us he (pbuh) was a JEW? During the Jesus' life on earth there was no such thing as a "christian" - He was never crucified, and if someone was crucified in his place is something we do not know for sure - if someone was crucified, they would have been crucified by both jews and pagan romans. Remember, Jesus was a nabi sent to the the jews of his time who had strayed away from the path of Allah - shortly before his birth the Pharisees got together and decided that Judaism would transform from a Propheticly led religion to a Rabinnacly led religion - they then wrote the Talmud. So Jesus was raised in a Talmudic Jewish society, unlike previous anbiya sent to Bani Israel. His message to the Jews at that time was basicly to abandon the man made laws of the Talmud. One law jews did not abandon was circumcision - and no uncircumcised person could be counted as a jew or set foot in the temple - Jesus was considered by the Jews, including Jewish historian Josephus to be "an important Rabbi" - so he was considered a Jew by the Jews, and one way one is confirmed as a jew in talmudic judaism is to have a Rabbi perform a ritual circumcission and confirm the childs Jewish heritage. So even though the Quran and hadeeth do not mention it, the other evidence surrounding his life leads us to deduce that Jesus Jewishness was confirmed, and to be confirmed a Jew, one must be circumcised.
	Quote