DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Machater** · 11-15-2011, 01:21 AM

First define biddah. Then answer is easy!
Does she consider this to be wajib or sunnah or this her preference to do things which she may find to be beneficial.
If one consider any extra thing to be wajib or sunnah then it is biddah. Is her action contray to shariah! from the sound of things she is not violating anything or even encouraging others to follow her example. Perhaps you can encourage her to do extra 2 rakah nawafil (salatul Awabin) salat after 7 rakah maghrib salat 3 fard, 2 sunnah 2 Nawafil. This way she will get alot more reward. Similarly she can perform extra 2 rakah after 20 minutes of sunrise . 2 rakah during dhurur time and 2 rakah after Isha salaat.

www.askimam.org, daruliftaa.com
Allahualam

Thanks a lot. I prety sure she prays all those raka'at masha Allah but I'll let her know anyways iA. when I first asked her about it, she reluctantly told me she does it because we're closest to Allah SWT in prostration and that she recites the names of Allah SWT out of politeness to Allah SWT.
May Allah SWT love her very much. Amin

So i suppose that wouldnt make it bi'da correct since she just likes to do it?

11-15-2011, 01:21 AM	#2
Machater Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 444 Senior Member	First define biddah. Then answer is easy! Does she consider this to be wajib or sunnah or this her preference to do things which she may find to be beneficial. If one consider any extra thing to be wajib or sunnah then it is biddah. Is her action contray to shariah! from the sound of things she is not violating anything or even encouraging others to follow her example. Perhaps you can encourage her to do extra 2 rakah nawafil (salatul Awabin) salat after 7 rakah maghrib salat 3 fard, 2 sunnah 2 Nawafil. This way she will get alot more reward. Similarly she can perform extra 2 rakah after 20 minutes of sunrise . 2 rakah during dhurur time and 2 rakah after Isha salaat. www.askimam.org, daruliftaa.com Allahualam Thanks a lot. I prety sure she prays all those raka'at masha Allah but I'll let her know anyways iA. when I first asked her about it, she reluctantly told me she does it because we're closest to Allah SWT in prostration and that she recites the names of Allah SWT out of politeness to Allah SWT. May Allah SWT love her very much. Amin So i suppose that wouldnt make it bi'da correct since she just likes to do it?
	Quote