DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Fertassa** · 09-28-2011, 05:22 AM

Outstanding answer!Thanks.My opinion is that they should have spread monotheism to as many nations as possible(like Muslims did from their birth as an Umma)as soon as they got out of Egypt under Moses,instead of exterminating the inhabitants of Canaan.Maybe God's plan was to give them guiding,prophets and a holy Book in order to spread tawheed all over the World.But they kept God for themselves only and that's why He eventually got fed up with them and sent Muhammad and the Quran in order to at last teach monotheism to everyone.Maybe,if they had spread monotheism to all nations,God would have never needed to send Muhammad to accomplish this.Can this be a possibility?

No, there are no "possibilities" when it comes to history in Islam. That is because everything that was preordained and predestined has come to pass. The Jews did what they did because they were meant to do it. The reality of the prophethood of Prophet Muhammad

existed before creation. So, nothing could have stopped Prophet Muhammad

from arriving in Makkah and declaring prophethood. The Christians, for example, did spread their message around the world, but their message was changed to that of polytheism pretty early on, with only a tiny and persecuted minority (branded as heretics by the Roman church) clinging on to the idea of the humanity of Jesus

and rejecting his divinity.

The problem with the Jews wasn't that they refused to spread monotheism around but their problem was that they used to and still do hide the laws of God in the Torah, making up excuses to exclude themselves from some laws (and even changing their book to suit them), as well as the fact that they attacked truthful messengers that were sent to them to set them straight. From even the time of Moses

you can see this rebellious nature. If a messenger of God shows you miracles and saves you from the worst fo oppressors through the will of God, would you turn around, forge a golden calf, and start worshiping it? Then when this messenger tells you, "Enter this city and it will be yours," would you reply, "You and your god can go; we'll just sit around here"?

This was the nature of the Jews at the time of Moses

.

Compare that with the companions

of our Prophet Muhammad

. Once they knew the truth, they would say, "We hear and we obey," whereas the Jews, once messengers were sent to them would say, "We hear and we disobey." When Moses

was sent, they rejected him over and over again until they reached their destination after years of wandering. When Jesus

was sent to them, they rejected him and conspired to get him killed - and if the Christian narrative is to be believed, they were quite successful at it (and in spite of what the politically correct view says, the truth is that the Jewish sanhedrin was behind the charges and were the principal callers for the killing of Christ).

09-28-2011, 05:22 AM	#37
Fertassa Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 506 Senior Member	Outstanding answer!Thanks.My opinion is that they should have spread monotheism to as many nations as possible(like Muslims did from their birth as an Umma)as soon as they got out of Egypt under Moses,instead of exterminating the inhabitants of Canaan.Maybe God's plan was to give them guiding,prophets and a holy Book in order to spread tawheed all over the World.But they kept God for themselves only and that's why He eventually got fed up with them and sent Muhammad and the Quran in order to at last teach monotheism to everyone.Maybe,if they had spread monotheism to all nations,God would have never needed to send Muhammad to accomplish this.Can this be a possibility? No, there are no "possibilities" when it comes to history in Islam. That is because everything that was preordained and predestined has come to pass. The Jews did what they did because they were meant to do it. The reality of the prophethood of Prophet Muhammad existed before creation. So, nothing could have stopped Prophet Muhammad from arriving in Makkah and declaring prophethood. The Christians, for example, did spread their message around the world, but their message was changed to that of polytheism pretty early on, with only a tiny and persecuted minority (branded as heretics by the Roman church) clinging on to the idea of the humanity of Jesus and rejecting his divinity. The problem with the Jews wasn't that they refused to spread monotheism around but their problem was that they used to and still do hide the laws of God in the Torah, making up excuses to exclude themselves from some laws (and even changing their book to suit them), as well as the fact that they attacked truthful messengers that were sent to them to set them straight. From even the time of Moses you can see this rebellious nature. If a messenger of God shows you miracles and saves you from the worst fo oppressors through the will of God, would you turn around, forge a golden calf, and start worshiping it? Then when this messenger tells you, "Enter this city and it will be yours," would you reply, "You and your god can go; we'll just sit around here"? This was the nature of the Jews at the time of Moses . Compare that with the companions of our Prophet Muhammad . Once they knew the truth, they would say, "We hear and we obey," whereas the Jews, once messengers were sent to them would say, "We hear and we disobey." When Moses was sent, they rejected him over and over again until they reached their destination after years of wandering. When Jesus was sent to them, they rejected him and conspired to get him killed - and if the Christian narrative is to be believed, they were quite successful at it (and in spite of what the politically correct view says, the truth is that the Jewish sanhedrin was behind the charges and were the principal callers for the killing of Christ).
	Quote