[Mambattedge]

Asalaamualaykum.

You are right.. I will leave the personal views aside.. and only deal with subject here..


I am fully aware of Mufti desai and his fatwas sidi and he does what he is able within his own limited ablity as a hanifi mufti , sometimes he makes a mistake and thats what is human about us all, we all make mistakes and make judgements we later repent from. For one sure thing, mufti desai has not made any mistake here. you simply lack knowledge and understanding to tackle the issue.

I repect and love Mufti Desai although i disagree with some minor issues, we cannot all agree and thats a fact of life.

Each to their own and may ALLAH guide us all always ameen

ma salaama and sidi this is where you completely do not understand.. You do not have the right or the capacity to disagree with Mufti Desai He is a hanafi Mufti.. You are a maliki. His opinion does not concern you. and even if it did, you are a layman ... your diagreement will mean nothing in academic arena.

Secondly, If anything can be said here for the benefit of the thread .. it has to be from Hanafi view, and not opinions of other madhahib.. We cannot and do not enforce our view on anyone...