DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Anakattawl** · 08-24-2008, 04:09 AM

You are right.. I will leave the personal views aside.. and only deal with subject here..

For one sure thing, mufti desai has not made any mistake here. you simply lack knowledge and understanding to tackle the issue.

and sidi this is where you completely do not understand.. You do not have the right or the capacity to disagree with Mufti Desai

Secondly, If anything can be said here for the benefit of the thread .. it has to be from Hanafi view, and not opinions of other madhahib.. We cannot and do not enforce our view on anyone...

Asalaamualaykum.

Quote You do not have the right or the capacity to disagree with Mufti Desai

As you dont know me in person i suggest you dont make such alarming claims of one being intellectually challanged in respect to Mufi or you in that matter.

As for the capacity to reason well I am fully aware of my own knowledge of such matters within maliki fiqh and also from the veiw point of the scholars from among the shia ulama of Qom and Isfahaan.

You see sidi i may not be a scholar in the modernist technical term but ALLAH knows my ability to make a just intellectual response from my heart to queston what i seem fit ! this is my given right as a human being.

Are you saying that people cannot queston scholars ?

As for not having a right to disagree well sorry but iam not into facism i beleve that all people have a right to speak out, one cannot shut people up with such beliefs sidi , i think you are over stepping the mark here in adab and courtesy and i say with respect, please alter the tone here for all you do is belittle intellectualism .

Let people speak out and queston everything because thats how the truth is heard.

08-24-2008, 04:09 AM	#32
Anakattawl Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 551 Senior Member	You are right.. I will leave the personal views aside.. and only deal with subject here.. For one sure thing, mufti desai has not made any mistake here. you simply lack knowledge and understanding to tackle the issue. and sidi this is where you completely do not understand.. You do not have the right or the capacity to disagree with Mufti Desai Secondly, If anything can be said here for the benefit of the thread .. it has to be from Hanafi view, and not opinions of other madhahib.. We cannot and do not enforce our view on anyone... Asalaamualaykum. Quote You do not have the right or the capacity to disagree with Mufti Desai As you dont know me in person i suggest you dont make such alarming claims of one being intellectually challanged in respect to Mufi or you in that matter. As for the capacity to reason well I am fully aware of my own knowledge of such matters within maliki fiqh and also from the veiw point of the scholars from among the shia ulama of Qom and Isfahaan. You see sidi i may not be a scholar in the modernist technical term but ALLAH knows my ability to make a just intellectual response from my heart to queston what i seem fit ! this is my given right as a human being. Are you saying that people cannot queston scholars ? As for not having a right to disagree well sorry but iam not into facism i beleve that all people have a right to speak out, one cannot shut people up with such beliefs sidi , i think you are over stepping the mark here in adab and courtesy and i say with respect, please alter the tone here for all you do is belittle intellectualism . Let people speak out and queston everything because thats how the truth is heard.
	Quote