DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Age Of Aisha (R.A.) at the time of marriage?

**janeseymore09092** · 10-06-2011, 12:19 AM

there is a valid point that this hadeeth regarding ayesha's age is narrated from a sahaba and not narrated from ayesha herself or the prophet, so even though its in bukhari, it only means the chain is authenticly linked back to urwah. Its doesnt prove that urwah was correct in his oppinion.

Another question to the OP, can you give any examples in bukhari or muslim where things are authentically narrated by sahaba's but the sahaba were incorrect in their statement. For example, erroneous fiqh rulings (I believe some of the sahaba held mutah and music and other things to be halal for example, can this be traced back to bukhari or muslim?)

Akhi I posted the Asaneed above can't you see that it's narrated from Hisham ibn 'Urwah (rah) who heard it from 'Urwah ibn al-Zubair (ra) who heard it from 'Aisha (as)... thus it's in fact 'Aisha (ra) who is narrating this about herself.

Ibn 'Abbas (ra) held that Muta'ah was allowed in extreme cases but all the other companions (ra) disagreed with him and narrated what they heard from the Prophet SAWS in forbidding Muta'ah.

10-06-2011, 12:19 AM	#13
janeseymore09092 Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 410 Senior Member	there is a valid point that this hadeeth regarding ayesha's age is narrated from a sahaba and not narrated from ayesha herself or the prophet, so even though its in bukhari, it only means the chain is authenticly linked back to urwah. Its doesnt prove that urwah was correct in his oppinion. Another question to the OP, can you give any examples in bukhari or muslim where things are authentically narrated by sahaba's but the sahaba were incorrect in their statement. For example, erroneous fiqh rulings (I believe some of the sahaba held mutah and music and other things to be halal for example, can this be traced back to bukhari or muslim?) Akhi I posted the Asaneed above can't you see that it's narrated from Hisham ibn 'Urwah (rah) who heard it from 'Urwah ibn al-Zubair (ra) who heard it from 'Aisha (as)... thus it's in fact 'Aisha (ra) who is narrating this about herself. Ibn 'Abbas (ra) held that Muta'ah was allowed in extreme cases but all the other companions (ra) disagreed with him and narrated what they heard from the Prophet SAWS in forbidding Muta'ah.
	Quote