DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - legs to legs and shoulder's to shoulders during namaz in jamath..

**CHEAPPoem** · 09-20-2011, 03:01 AM

Do you know any scholar of the past who said that we have to literally join our feets? Maybe some of the zahiris but even then it will not result in an ikhtilaf. ikhtilaf is only possible within the four schools.

this is also not possible.

its definitely possible to join your ankles. That being said, you raise some good points regarding 1 the hadeeth mentions knees also and 2 is there an ulema of the past who held the position so inshAllah I shall find out about them and get back to you. I dont agree that its only validn ikhtilaaf if the four schools held the oppinion though, it sorta spits in teh face of the other ulema of the past who were just as high if not higher than the four imams in status who held differing oppinions, so I dont accept that point. I will try find out who has ever said that ankles should be joined though inshAllah.

My main point was the terrible adaab and repulsive manners in this thread though, and many others, in this forum and others, that will drive any potential muslims far away from islam. Im lucky I became a muslim and THEN met the muslim community alhamdulillah. I grew up in the sticks in rural somerset where islam is virtually non existent. Had I have seen these sorts of threads I would have probabily joined a different religion (I was considering becoming buddist when I stumbled accross islam in morocco). Im just being honest. Serious, muslims have serious akhlaaq issues. People fight over whos following bukhari. Imam bukhari rahimahullah, in his first chapter, kitabul IMAAN, quotes many ahadeeth in manners towards your muslim brothers, these are manners that most seem to have forgotten. Think about what the ansar did for the muhajiroon. SubhanAllah, how far away we are from this

09-20-2011, 03:01 AM	#17
CHEAPPoem Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 564 Senior Member	Do you know any scholar of the past who said that we have to literally join our feets? Maybe some of the zahiris but even then it will not result in an ikhtilaf. ikhtilaf is only possible within the four schools. this is also not possible. its definitely possible to join your ankles. That being said, you raise some good points regarding 1 the hadeeth mentions knees also and 2 is there an ulema of the past who held the position so inshAllah I shall find out about them and get back to you. I dont agree that its only validn ikhtilaaf if the four schools held the oppinion though, it sorta spits in teh face of the other ulema of the past who were just as high if not higher than the four imams in status who held differing oppinions, so I dont accept that point. I will try find out who has ever said that ankles should be joined though inshAllah. My main point was the terrible adaab and repulsive manners in this thread though, and many others, in this forum and others, that will drive any potential muslims far away from islam. Im lucky I became a muslim and THEN met the muslim community alhamdulillah. I grew up in the sticks in rural somerset where islam is virtually non existent. Had I have seen these sorts of threads I would have probabily joined a different religion (I was considering becoming buddist when I stumbled accross islam in morocco). Im just being honest. Serious, muslims have serious akhlaaq issues. People fight over whos following bukhari. Imam bukhari rahimahullah, in his first chapter, kitabul IMAAN, quotes many ahadeeth in manners towards your muslim brothers, these are manners that most seem to have forgotten. Think about what the ansar did for the muhajiroon. SubhanAllah, how far away we are from this
	Quote